The Best New True Crime Podcast Right Now – November 2025
Dive into the darkest corners of true crime with our latest blog series! We're dissecting 10 gripping episodes, from the mysterious death of Christian Olsen and the tragic cold case of Martha Mezzo and Teresa Flores, to the complex Amber Spradlin investigation and the baffling Crystal Rogers disappearance. We'll also explore the chilling Dateline cases of Ashley Schwamm and Dr. Stephen Schwartz, revisit the Amber Spradlin and Cal Harris updates, and touch upon the Allison Feldman murder and the Brian Walsh case. Tune in to uncover the details, the theories, and the ongoing pursuit of justice in these compelling true crime stories.
The 10 Best True Crime episodes
MURDERED: Christion Olson
The podcast investigates the suspicious death of Christian Olsen, exploring conflicting accounts, forensic evidence, and theories of foul play.
This podcast delves into the mysterious death of 18-year-old Christian Olsen, who was found deceased after a party. Initial reports suggested intoxication, but autopsy results revealed blunt force trauma, leading to a homicide ruling. The investigation is hampered by inconsistent testimonies from friends, the lack of surveillance footage, and challenges in accessing encrypted phone data. Theories range from a physical altercation to a hit-and-run or retaliation for a past robbery, but no definitive conclusion has been reached. The case highlights the difficulties in solving crimes with limited evidence and the importance of community cooperation.
MURDERED: Teresa Flores & Martha Mezo
This episode details the 1980 San Miguel murders of two young girls, exploring the complex investigation, forensic advancements, and enduring mystery.
This episode of Crime Junkie delves into the tragic 1980 disappearance and murder of four-year-old Martha Mezzo and five-year-old Teresa Flores in San Miguel, California. The investigation was hampered by initial reporting delays and a vast pool of potential suspects, including troubled teens, known offenders, and even a serial killer whose confession proved false. Key evidence, such as ligatures and distinctive underwear, became crucial as forensic technology evolved. Decades later, DNA analysis of semen on the underwear and unidentified DNA on other items provided new leads, though the case remains a cold case. Detective Cole's renewed investigation explores theories of multiple perpetrators and the possibility of a prank gone wrong, with genealogy DNA analysis and the rediscovery of crucial evidence offering hope for a resolution.
INFAMOUS: The Murder of Amber Spradlin
This podcast delves into the Amber Spradlin murder case, exploring alleged cover-ups, a flawed justice system, and the fight for justice, alongside advertisements and a mention of a nominated novel.
This podcast episode focuses on the complex and tragic case of Amber Spradlin from Eastern Kentucky. The hosts, Ashley Flowers and Britt, detail the suspicious circumstances surrounding Amber's death, the initial investigation, and the subsequent arrest of MK McKinney, son of Michael McKinney. The narrative highlights community outrage over alleged cover-ups, the influence of the powerful McKinney family, and a history of unresolved suspicious deaths in Floyd County. The episode also touches upon evidence tampering charges, MK's alleged violent history, and the defense's strategy. Delays in forensic testing are identified as a major hurdle, leading to the proposed "Amber's Law" to improve crime lab funding. The family's ongoing pursuit of justice and their hope to bring attention to other unsolved cases are emphasized. Interspersed within the case discussion are advertisements for American Home Shield, Capital One, Simply Safe, T-Mobile 5G Home Internet, MidiHealth, JCPenney, Blue Apron, Peloton, and McDonald's, as well as a mention of the author's novel "The Missing Half" being nominated for a Goodreads Choice Award.
The Trouble in Bardstown
The podcast details the complex and tragic disappearance of Crystal Rogers, the subsequent murder of her father, and the interconnected unsolved cases in Bardstown, Kentucky, culminating in arrests and convictions.
This podcast chronicles the baffling disappearance of Crystal Rogers in 2015 from Bardstown, Kentucky, a town plagued by a series of unsolved murders. The investigation into Crystal's vanishing, marked by the discovery of her abandoned car and inconsistencies in her boyfriend Brooks Hauke's account, spanned years. Her father, Tommy Ballard, relentlessly pursued his own investigation, only to be tragically murdered himself. The FBI's "Operation Justice Rising" connected Crystal's disappearance to the murders of Tommy Ballard and Officer Jason Ellis, suspecting a wider conspiracy. Key developments included forensic evidence from Crystal's car, phone data placing Brooks's employee Steve Lawson at the scene, and eventual confessions. The trial focused on circumstantial evidence, leading to the conviction of Brooks Hauke for murder and lesser charges for Steve and Joey Lawson. The episode highlights the deep-seated issues and patterns of violence in Bardstown, leaving some cases, like Jason Ellis's murder, still unresolved.
Running Man
A Dateline investigation into Ashley Schwamm's death reveals a meticulously planned murder by her husband, James, who staged a fatal car crash to cover his tracks.
This Dateline episode chronicles the investigation into the death of Ashley Schwamm, initially reported as a fatal car accident. As detectives delved deeper, inconsistencies at the crash scene and autopsy results pointed towards homicide. The investigation focused on Ashley's husband, James Schwamm, a firefighter, who initially appeared cooperative but exhibited suspicious behavior and provided a questionable alibi. Evidence, including witness accounts, security footage of a "Running Man" near the crash site, and eventually a Zippo lighter with James's initials found in Ashley's burned SUV, built a case against him. The narrative explores James's potential motives, including financial gain and a desire for a new relationship, and details how he allegedly murdered Ashley, staged the crash, and attempted to cover his tracks. The episode concludes with James's arrest, his plea to second-degree murder, and the profound impact on Ashley's family.
Kentucky prosecutor wants trial of dentist's son delayed. Cal Harris sues cops. Plus, rental scams.
Dateline True Crime Weekly covers a Kentucky dentist's son accused of murder, Cal Harris's civil suit after acquittal, and updates on other cases, plus social media rental scams.
This episode of Dateline True Crime Weekly features several compelling cases. It begins with the murder of Amber Spradlin in Kentucky, where the son of a dentist, MK, is accused of the crime, and his father faces charges for alleged evidence tampering. The investigation into the events leading to Spradlin's death and the subsequent cover-up attempts are detailed. The program also revisits the case of Cal Harris, who was acquitted of his wife's murder after multiple trials and subsequently sued investigators for malicious prosecution. Further updates are provided on the murders of Cata Scott and Angie Solomon, as well as Dan Serafini's bid for a new trial due to alleged juror misconduct. Finally, the episode includes a warning about the rise of sophisticated rental scams on social media platforms.
DNA at heart of Arizona trial. Aspiring model's killer fights to clear his name. Plus, Relisha Rudd.
This podcast covers NFL football, true crime cases like Allison Feldman and Karen Hernslover, and the disappearance of Relisha Rudd, with updates on Brian Coburger and Sandra Birchmore.
This podcast delves into various topics, starting with Thumbtack's service for home projects and the NFL's presence on the Today Show. It then transitions to true crime, discussing Dateline's weekly docket, the Allison Feldman murder trial involving familial DNA testing, and the Karen Hernslover case with the Illinois Innocence Project's involvement. Updates are provided on the Brian Coburger and Sandra Birchmore cases, as well as the disappearance of Relisha Rudd, highlighting the work of the Black and Missing Foundation.
Talking Dateline: The Trouble in Bardstown
This Dateline episode investigates the unsolved murders in Bardstown, KY, focusing on the Crystal Rogers case and the lingering questions surrounding other deaths.
This Dateline episode delves into the series of unsolved murders in Bardstown, Kentucky, primarily focusing on the disappearance and presumed murder of Crystal Rogers. The investigation highlights the conviction of her ex-boyfriend, Brooks Hauke, while acknowledging that Crystal's body has never been found. The discussion expands to include the murders of Crystal's father, Tommy Ballard, and police officer Jason Ellis, with the FBI suspecting a connection between these cases. The episode explores the challenges faced by law enforcement in a close-knit town, the complexities of family dynamics, and the emotional toll on the victims' families, particularly Crystal's mother, Sherry Ballard. It also touches upon the legal strategies, the role of evidence, and the public's distrust of media, while expressing hope for future resolutions and justice for all victims.
Talking Dateline: The Death of Dr. Schwartz
Dateline investigates Dr. Schwartz's murder, revealing his hidden past, Rebecca's alleged involvement, Leo's confession, and legal complexities.
This Dateline episode delves into the murder of Dr. Stephen Schwartz, initially appearing as a burglary but revealing a complex web of financial motives, betrayal, and hidden pasts. The investigation highlights the suspected involvement of his wife, Rebecca, and Leo's confession, where he claimed manipulation. The narrative explores Dr. Schwartz's own past as a convicted murderer, raising questions about redemption. Legal aspects, including the difference between civil and criminal charges and a substantial civil judgment against Rebecca, are discussed. The episode also touches on the challenges of investigative journalism, memory, and the pursuit of justice, concluding with listener engagement and a brief mention of another case.
An accused killer pleads guilty, but not to murder. The next chapter in the Dulos case. Plus, a NXIVM story.
This podcast covers true crime cases including Brian Walsh's plea, Michelle Traconis' appeal, and Alison Mack's Nexium involvement, alongside manufacturing and brain health topics.
This podcast delves into several true crime cases, beginning with the Brian Walsh case, where he pleaded guilty to lesser charges related to his wife Anna Walsh's disappearance and murder. The narrative explores potential motives, investigative evidence like suspicious Google searches and GPS data, and the dramatic turn of events including Walsh being stabbed in jail. Updates are provided on the Michelle Traconis appeal concerning the Jennifer Farber-Doulos murder, focusing on arguments about evidence admissibility and police interviews. The podcast also touches on the Karen Reed lawsuit, alleging she was framed for John O'Keefe's death, and the murder of "Last Chance U" coach John Beam. A significant portion is dedicated to actress Alison Mack's reflections on her involvement in the Nexium sex cult, detailing its structure and her role in recruiting women. Criminology students' success in solving a cold case is also highlighted. The episode opens with a brief mention of Granger's role in manufacturing maintenance and a public health message about prioritizing brain health and dementia risk factors.
The Best New True Crime Podcast Right Now – September 2025
The Best New True Crime Podcast Right Now – October 2025
The Best New True Crime Podcast Right Now – June 2025