Discover
BETH'S DEAD
BETH'S DEAD
Author: Monica Padman, Elizabeth Laime, Andy Rosen
Subscribed: 4,331Played: 16,678Subscribe
Share
© 2025
Description
Beth's Dead is a new kind of true crime podcast. Brought to you by Armchair Expert's Monica Padman, and Nobody's Listening, Right? this limited mystery series explores what happens when parasocial relationships go terribly wrong.
As Monica interviews her favorite podcasters, Elizabeth Laime and Andy Rosen, about why they shut down their mini podcasting empire years ago, a story unfolds that is so shocking and creepy, it's hard to believe. That's when Monica takes on the role of a real-life Nancy Drew, setting out to get answers and to unravel a mystery they thought was long behind them.
New episodes release weekly or to binge the entire ad-free BETH'S DEAD series NOW + connect with other fans, go to: www.Patreon.com/BethsDead
As Monica interviews her favorite podcasters, Elizabeth Laime and Andy Rosen, about why they shut down their mini podcasting empire years ago, a story unfolds that is so shocking and creepy, it's hard to believe. That's when Monica takes on the role of a real-life Nancy Drew, setting out to get answers and to unravel a mystery they thought was long behind them.
New episodes release weekly or to binge the entire ad-free BETH'S DEAD series NOW + connect with other fans, go to: www.Patreon.com/BethsDead
8 Episodes
Reverse
Armchair Expert's Monica Padman always wondered why her favorite podcasters, Elizabeth and Andy, abruptly ended their show years ago. She assumed they'd say the usual - they got burnt out or busy with other things, but the truth was a story so shocking and creepy that she knew they had to make a show about it... What she couldn't have expected is that in listening to their true life cautionary tale, she'd take on the role of a real-life Nancy Drew and get wrapped up in the mystery as well. To binge the entire series + connect with other BETH'S DEAD fans visit: www.Patreon.com/BethsDead
Armchair Expert's Monica Padman talks to her favorite podcasters, Elizabeth Laime and Andy Rosen (from Nobody's Listening, Right?), about how she first found their show, why they stopped and what prompted this entire true crime series - that takes a hard look at the two way street of parasocial relationships. If you don't want to wait for more BETH'S DEAD, you can binge the entire series + connect with other fans at www.Patreon.com/BethsDead BETH'S DEAD is a limited true crime and mystery series that takes a look at what happens when parasocial relationships go terribly wrong. Brought to you by Armchair Expert's Monica Padman, in collaboration with Elizabeth Laime and Andy Rosen of Nobody's Listening, Right? Credits Produced and Edited by Andy Rosen, Elizabeth Laime, and Monica Padman Additional Engineering by Rob Holysz Music and Sound by Andy Rosen
Monica, Elizabeth and Andy reflect on their interactions with their podcast listeners - and there's one who stands out in particular. If you don't want to wait for more BETH'S DEAD, you can binge the entire series + connect with other fans at www.Patreon.com/BethsDead BETH'S DEAD is a limited true crime and mystery series that takes a look at what happens when parasocial relationships go terribly wrong. Brought to you by Armchair Expert's Monica Padman, in collaboration with Elizabeth Laime and Andy Rosen of Nobody's Listening, Right? Credits Produced and Edited by Andy Rosen, Elizabeth Laime, and Monica Padman Additional Engineering by Rob Holysz Music and Sound by Andy Rosen
Andy finds out just how deeply involved Elizabeth got with Beth as Monica guides them through the correspondence. If you don't want to wait for more BETH'S DEAD, you can binge the entire series + connect with other fans at www.Patreon.com/BethsDead BETH'S DEAD is a limited true crime and mystery series that takes a look at what happens when parasocial relationships go terribly wrong. Brought to you by Armchair Expert's Monica Padman, in collaboration with Elizabeth Laime and Andy Rosen of Nobody's Listening, Right? Credits Produced and Edited by Andy Rosen, Elizabeth Laime, and Monica Padman Additional Engineering by Rob Holysz Music and Sound by Andy Rosen
Monica listens as Elizabeth and Andy re-live the moment they learned that what they thought they knew about Beth wasn't the whole truth. If you don't want to wait for more BETH'S DEAD, you can binge the entire series + connect with other fans at www.Patreon.com/BethsDead Special thanks to Andrea Tomingas from Duck Bridgade - our amazing web designer who was mentioned in this episode. BETH'S DEAD is a limited true crime and mystery series that takes a look at what happens when parasocial relationships go terribly wrong. Brought to you by Armchair Expert's Monica Padman, in collaboration with Elizabeth Laime and Andy Rosen of Nobody's Listening, Right? Credits Produced and Edited by Andy Rosen, Elizabeth Laime, and Monica Padman Additional Engineering by Rob Holysz Music and Sound by Andy Rosen
*Possible spoilers in description below_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Elizabeth and Andy share with Monica how they solved the mystery around Beth and how the police became involved. If you don't want to wait for more BETH'S DEAD, you can binge the entire series + connect with other fans at www.Patreon.com/BethsDead Special thanks to Andrea Tomingas from Duck Bridgade - our amazing web designer who participated in this episode. BETH'S DEAD is a limited true crime and mystery series that takes a look at what happens when parasocial relationships go terribly wrong. Brought to you by Armchair Expert's Monica Padman, in collaboration with Elizabeth Laime and Andy Rosen of Nobody's Listening, Right? Credits: Produced and Edited by Andy Rosen, Elizabeth Laime, and Monica Padman Additional Engineering by Rob Holysz Music and Sound by Andy Rosen
*Possible spoilers in description below_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________Monica, Elizabeth and Andy try to lighten the mood by looking back at other listener emails but only end up getting even more creeped out. If you don't want to wait for more BETH'S DEAD, you can binge the entire series + connect with other fans at www.Patreon.com/BethsDead BETH'S DEAD is a limited true crime and mystery series that takes a look at what happens when parasocial relationships go terribly wrong. Brought to you by Armchair Expert's Monica Padman, in collaboration with Elizabeth Laime and Andy Rosen of Nobody's Listening, Right? Credits: Produced and Edited by Andy Rosen, Elizabeth Laime, and Monica Padman Additional Engineering by Rob Holysz Music and Sound by Andy Rosen
*Possible spoilers in description below_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Monica, Elizabeth and Andy talk to an internet expert (Evita March) and a private investigator to help them understand what they might be getting themselves into. If you don't want to wait for more BETH'S DEAD, you can binge the entire series + connect with other fans at www.Patreon.com/BethsDead BETH'S DEAD is a limited true crime and mystery series that takes a look at what happens when parasocial relationships go terribly wrong. Brought to you by Armchair Expert's Monica Padman, in collaboration with Elizabeth Laime and Andy Rosen of Nobody's Listening, Right? Credits: Produced and Edited by Andy Rosen, Elizabeth Laime, and Monica Padman Additional Engineering by Rob Holysz Music and Sound by Andy Rosen Special Thanks to Evita March for participating in this episode.












Best episode yet. Usually the expert episode on podcasts is boring bonus content, but she was great! The statistics were so interesting. The second half was equally as revelatory and exciting.
Wow, this sounds super intriguing! I love when a podcast mixes real-life mystery with a personal journey — the fact that Monica Padman becomes a sort of real-life detective makes it even more exciting. Can’t wait to listen and find out what really happened with Elizabeth and Andy!
Just discovered the “BETH’S DEAD” podcast — the premise sounds super intriguing! https://run3-online.io