Claim Ownership


Subscribed: 0Played: 0


A family of three vanishes in the mountains. Four years later, their remains are discovered less than three miles from where their vehicle was located. With theories ranging from cults to drugs to murder suicide, the question remains—what happened to the Jamison family? Sponsors: Factor: and use code prosecutors50 to get 50% off. Prose: for an in-depth hair consultation and get 50% off your first subscription order today PLUS 15% off and free shipping every subscription order after that Huggies Progressive Insurance PlutoTV Nighty Night Podcast Resources: The strange disappearance and deaths of the Jamison Family in the Sans Bois mountains — Gone Without a Trace: The Mysterious Disappearance of the Jamison Family - The CrimeWire The Jamison Family's Disappearance And The Story Behind It ( The Chilling Disappearance Of The Jamison Family ( True Crime — What Happened to the Jamison Family? | by Skylar Aries | Medium The Generation Why Podcast, Episode 217- Jamison Family Deaths, January 29, 2017 Disappeared, Season 2 Episode 10- Paradise Lost, December 6, 2010 Going West, Episode 14- The Jamison Family, March 4, 2019 
In a span of less than 20 months, five women vanished from the community of North Okanagan in British Columbia, Canada. Where did they go? Are they connected? And will these cases ever be solved? Sponsors:  Progressive Insurance PlutoTV Nighty Night Podcast Huggies Resources: The Largest And Smallest Canadian Provinces/Territories By Area - WorldAtlas More people go missing in BC than anywhere else in Canada. No one knows why - Capital Daily Missing and Murdered Aboriginal Women ( Caitlin Potts left sister chilling last message before she disappeared from B.C. Interior | CBC News The British Columbia Triangle: 4/6 – Missing Women of the Northern Okanagan ( Ashley Simpson’s remains found, boyfriend charged with murder | The Star 2½-year-old mystery of woman's disappearance deepens with discovery of ID in sewage truck | CBC News Boyfriend charged with 2016 murder of Ashley Simpson near Salmon Arm, B.C. | CBC News More details emerge in Ashley Simpson missing person case | The British Columbia Triangle: 2/6 – Unsolved Disappearances in Canada ( RCMP ask for public help in missing woman investigation | 
We take another look at the crimes of Mark Twitchell, but this time we bring an expert--Julia Cowley, retired FBI profiler, and host of the acclaimed true crime podcast, The Consult: Real FBI Profilers. She reveals what she learned when she profiled Twitchell and offers up insights you will not believe.  Subscribe to her podcast here: Sponsors: Nighty Night Podcast PlutoTV Angi Noom HelloFresh: and use code tpfree for FREE breakfast for life! ZocDoc: Progressive 
When Devin Williams left on a routine trip in his 18-wheeler, he never could have known he'd end up in a national park in one of Arizona's most enduring mysteries. Sponsors: Huggies  This show is sponsored by Better Help: for 10 percent off First Leaf: Earth Breeze: for 40% off PlutoTV Nighty Night podcast Noom
If you see a large dark figure like that of man but with wings and glowing red eyes, know that doom is coming. Sponsors: Bad Bad Thing PlutoTV Progressive Insurance ZocDoc: and download the Zocdoc app for FREE. Resources: Bedtime Stories The Why Files The Mothman Prophecies Astonishing Legends Search for the Mothman
(This episode originally aired on our other show, Legal Briefs. If you enjoy these deep dives into interesting areas of the law, check it out: FBI CAST Agent Jay Berni joins the show to talk all things cell phones. How does cell phone analysis work? How accurate is it? And how is it getting even better as technology develops?
Mark Twitchell's friends knew he wanted to create horror movies that would shock audiences. They never imagined he'd turn his own life into one.  Sponsors: Bad Bad Thing Podcast Progressive Insurance PlutoTV HelloFresh: and use code 50tp for 50% off plus free shipping! Resources: The Devils Cinema Dark Poutine The One Who Got Away
Untreated mental illness culminates in the Halloween massacre of a family. Could it have been prevented? Or was the horror that happened inevitable?  Sponsors: One Minute Remaining Podcast PlutoTV Noom FirstLeaf: ZocDoc Resources: Black, Caroline. “Ohio Triple Murder: Teen Thought It WasHalloween Prank.” CBS News, 2 Nov. 2010,   Dziemianowicz, Joe. “Ohio Man Targets His Family in‘Real-Life Horror Story on Halloween.’” Oxygen Official Site, 10 Oct.2022,   Fuqua, Lisa Marie. “BJ Liske Butchers Family onHalloween?-?True Crime.” Medium, 1 Oct. 2019, Kennedy , Bruce. “Halloween Horror.” Homicide for theHolidays, season 4, episode 5, Oxygen , 7 Oct. 2022., and Legacy. “Derek Griffin Obituary (2010) - OakHarbor, OH - the Blade.” Legacy.Com, 3 Nov. 2010,, and Legacy. “Susan Liske Obituary (2010) - OakHarbor, OH - the Blade.” Legacy.Com, 3 Nov. 2010,, and Legacy. “William Liske Obituary (2010) - OakHarbor, OH - the Blade.” Legacy.Com, 3 Nov. 2010,   Proffitt, James. “Judge Sets Bail for Liske at $3M.” NewsHerald, 11 Nov. 2010, pp. A1–A2. Newspapers.Com,   Proffitt, James. “Liske Gets 3 Life Sentences .” TheNews-Messenger, 15 Sept. 2011, pp. A1–A2. Newspapers.Com,   Proffitt, James. “Man Pleads Guilty to Murdering 3 .” TheNewark Advocate, 13 Aug. 2011, p. 2. Newspapers.Com,   Proffitt, James. “Reports: Man Accused of Homicide HadTroubled Past .” News Herald , 9 Nov. 2010, pp. 1–2. Newspapers.Com,   Shoup, Craig. Confessed Murderer Found Dead in Cell ,18 Apr. 2015, p. A1. Newspapers.Com,   Ulloa, Gabriela. “‘Asesino de Halloween’: La Historia DelJoven Que Mató a Toda Su Familia En Noche de Brujas.” BioBioChile, 31Oct. 2021,  
Ruthie Mae McCoy knew the ABLA apartments in Chicago were a dangerous place. But she never could have imagined what horror could come through the mirror.  Sources:  Sponsors: This podcast is sponsored by BetterHelp. today to get 10% off your first month. Noom PlutoTV Bad Bad Thing Podcast Progressive Hello Fresh: Go to and use code 50tp for 50% off plus free shipping
Always check your candy.  Sponsors: PlutoTV Noom Progressive Insurance EarthBreeze: for 40 percent off Bad Bad Thing Podcast Resources:  TheHaunting Legacy of Ronald Clark O'Bryan, the Man Who Killed Halloween - A&ETrue Crime (  TheTrue Story of the Notorious Trick-or-Treat Murderer (  TexasExecution Information - History (  DeathRow Information (  Killer Legends  Death Makes a Holiday : a cultural history of Halloween byDavid J. Skal, Introduction: The Candyman’s Tale  TheVictoria Advocate - Google News Archive Search  TexasDeaths, 1890-1976;  'CandyMan's legacy still haunting today (  Theneighbor who accompanied condemned killer Ronald Clark O'Bryan... -UPI Archives  
Bonus: Thank You

Bonus: Thank You


We won an award! And we could not have done it without you...and some friends.
We conclude our coverage of the Brianna Maitland case.  Sponsors: PlutoTV The Jordan Harbinger Show Noom DoorDash
On March 19, 2004 at 11:20PM, 17-year-old Brianna Maitland clocked out of her shift at the Black Lantern Inn. But what happened next? Nobody knows, and Brianna was never seen or heard from again. Her car, however, was found. And the picture taken of it has haunted investigators ever since. Sponsors: Hello Fresh -- Go to and use code 50tp for 50% off plus 15% off the next 2 months ZocDoc -- PIs for the Missing Progressive Insurance The Schaub Show PlutoTV
Along a beautiful stretch of roadway, tragedy lurks. Why are so many women murdered on the highway of tears? Sponsors: Strictly Stalking PlutoTV EarthBreeze -- for 40% off! Progressive Insurance Deadly Nightmares
Originally on The Prosecutors: Legal Briefs. Shawn Rech freed an innocent man with the groundbreaking documentary, Murder in the Park. Now he takes on one of the most controversial innocence cases out there--that of Steven Avery. He tells us all about his newest project, Convicting a Murderer, which raises some disturbing questions about the motives and manipulations behind the Netflix blockbuster, Making a Murderer.
And now for something completely different. The moon has always been with us. Or has it? And is it actually hollow? And maybe a lot more than that? We get to the bottom (center?) of this celestial mystery. Sponsors: Deadly Nightmares podcast HelloFresh: Go to and use code 50tp for 50% off plus 15% off the next 2 months Strictly Stalking PlutoTV This podcast is sponsored by Better Help. today to get 10% off your first month.
We get it. Fourteen episodes and countless hours is a lot. So if you just want our theories, here they are. Enjoy.
After 13 episodes, we are finally here. In our final episode, we examine the case against Adnan Syed and present our theories of what happened to Hae Min Lee. And Alice calls down the thunder.  Sponsors: Earth Breeze: for 40% off! Strictly Stalking Podcast FabFitFun: Resources: Colin Miller's Likeliest Theory  The Wrongful Exoneration of Adnan Syed Part I: A Straightforward Murder Case by Andrew Hammel  The Wrongful Exoneration of Adnan Syed Part II: A Straightforward Murder Case  Cell Phone Location Testimony of FBI CAST Agent Chad Fitzgerald, Day 1  Cell Phone Location Testimony of FBI CAST Agent Chad Fitzgerald, Day 2  Defense Expert Cell Phone Location Testimony  Map Page Torn From Book  Photo of Rose in Back Seat  Description of Rose  List of Calls  Asia McClain PCR Testimony Day 1  Asia McClain PCR Testimony Day 2  Article on Alleged Brady Violation Note  Transcription of Alleged Brady Violation Note  Sellers Route to Work  State Appendix Including Defense File  Defense Interview with Adnan's Brother,...
In the first of two parts, we wrap up our discussion of the Hae Min Lee case with theories. In this episode, we discuss Don, Sellers, and Jay Wilds. Did they have the opportunity? The means? And the motive? Or do all signs point in a different direction? Sponsors: Earth Breeze: for 40% off! Strictly Stalking Podcast FabFitFun:
We review the expert testimony on the cell phone data in this case. What's reliable, what's not, and what does it all mean? Sponsors: Progressive Insurance Hello Fresh and use code 50tp for 50% off plus free shipping! PlutoTV Cold Case Files Podcast
Comments (154)


Terri killed Kyron. Not a new sad story but it infuriates more than most because it was premeditated. She planned the murder of a 7 year old boy that she had cared for since birth! Also, the idea that the husband was cheating on the wife while she was pregnant and then the woman murdered her son. No words for how angry I would be!

Nov 8th

Rachel Schommer

ugh...super Maga? Brett is even too unqualified for a Trump elected federal judge. yikes. unsubscribe.

Oct 31st

Aakash Amanat

I thoroughly enjoyed the latest episode of "The Prosecutors." The discussion on the complexities of modern-day criminal prosecution was both insightful and thought-provoking. The detailed analysis of the challenges faced by prosecutors in today's legal landscape, such as dealing with evolving technology, forensic evidence, and public opinion, shed light on the multifaceted nature of their work. Their perspective on the ethical considerations and moral dilemmas prosecutors often encounter was enlightening.

Oct 25th


I agree with Mark Twitchell that his Dexter obsession was overstated. seems the podcasters are always forcing the similarities.

Oct 24th

Melanie Marie-Jahnke Manning

Maybe I'm off, but I don't feel like most people believe in a conspiracy theory. I think most people who think Adnan is innocent, believe that he got railroaded by cops with tunnel vision. The issues that get brought up offer reasonable doubt, if anything.

Oct 16th

Arthur Davido

I've been in the IT field for a while now, and let me tell you, this Capstone Projects for Information Technology resource is a lifesaver! It's like a treasure trove of ideas and guidance. Whenever I need inspiration or some expert advice, this is my go-to spot. The capstone project writing services they offer are top-notch too, by the way. It's like having a team of pros right at your fingertips to help you tackle those complex projects. Kudos to the creators of this website!

Oct 12th

Melanie Marie-Jahnke Manning

if the prosecution says the murder happened at 2:36 and Adnan was at the library at 2:45, the he couldn't have killed Hae, UNLESS the prosecution allows for a different time of murder. A murder weapon (ie blow poke), doesn't change a timeframe or possibility of murder.

Oct 2nd


The Tyler Davis disappearance is another Columbus mystery. I would like to hear your theories on that one.

Sep 28th

Anthony Sweeney

Excellent analysis on a case with few real facts and I suspect they solved it, or at least came up with the most likely answer.

Sep 26th

Arthur Davido

I stumbled upon this gem while searching for paper writing services What a find! The FAQ section is like a crash course in choosing the right service, and the reviews are a game-changer. Can't wait to take a look at the site mentioned here and see if it lives up to the hype.

Sep 20th


Xanax with alcohol and pot can lead to all sorts of inexplicable outcomes.

Sep 16th


if u guys ever get the chance, the Sandy Rae case out of Shawnee, ok could really use some attn.. it's got all the elements of a great mystery-wealthy politicians, dirty cops, a very pretty, well liked, underprivileged 17 yr old girl who seemingly evaporated into thin air..

Sep 3rd


I gotta say, I've been on the side of Adnan until I heard Rabia's take on Scott Peterson being innocent. Now I question everything she has said.

Jul 14th


Anyone who believes a word Casey Anthony says is brainwashed by a rock.

Jul 10th


Great job on this case. So much info that was left out of the unsolved mysteries episode!

Jul 9th

Donna Cross

I LOVE you guys!!

Jun 29th

Lindsey Peyrot

I do love the Association of Realtors ad during this particular episode. Sweet, sweet irony.

Jun 22nd

Jayme Dailey

seriously? stop making small talk and start talking about the fucking story 😡

May 31st

Dianne Porter

It makes me physically ill to think that psychopath was not convicted...I feel she murdered her daughter out of "spite" to punish her parents for fight and eviction. Have to hope karma will have it's way with her... 😢

May 30th

Pam Corbishley

I don't know how you guys got through this episode without cracking up! Kudos!

Apr 11th
Download from Google Play
Download from App Store