DiscoverRates & Barrels: A show about Baseball2025 Starting Pitcher Preview, Part 1
2025 Starting Pitcher Preview, Part 1

2025 Starting Pitcher Preview, Part 1

Update: 2025-01-28
Share

Digest

This podcast delves into fantasy baseball pitcher rankings, categorizing them into tiers based on projected performance and draft position (ADP). The hosts discuss top-tier pitchers like Skenes, Skubal, and Wheeler, weighing their strengths, weaknesses, and injury risks. They then move to subsequent tiers, analyzing pitchers such as Burnes, Sale, and Kirby, emphasizing the importance of considering injury concerns and projected innings. The discussion includes a detailed breakdown of Bryce Miller's potential, his pitch arsenal development, and his suitability for various draft positions. Mid-round pitchers like Nola, Castillo, and Brown are also evaluated, along with high-ceiling, high-risk options like Sasaki and Green. The podcast concludes with a look at late-round sleepers, including Spencer Schwellenbach and Tanner Bibee, highlighting their potential value. Throughout the podcast, the hosts stress the critical role of injury risk assessment and the importance of balancing high-ceiling, high-risk pitchers with more reliable options in building a successful fantasy baseball team. Key factors considered include ADP, Stuff+, pitch arsenal, velocity, command, and projected innings.

Outlines

00:00:00
Introduction, Mint Mobile Ad & Fantasy Baseball Pitcher Overview

The podcast introduces the topic of fantasy baseball pitcher rankings and includes a brief advertisement for Mint Mobile. It sets the stage for a detailed analysis of pitchers across different draft tiers, emphasizing the importance of considering injury risk and ADP.

00:01:12
Tier 1 Pitcher Analysis: Elite Starters

Top-tier pitchers (Skenes, Skubal, Wheeler, Gilbert, Crochet) are analyzed, focusing on their strengths, weaknesses, and injury risks. The debate on drafting a pitcher in round one and roster construction challenges are discussed.

00:26:10
Tier 2 Pitcher Analysis: High-Value Starters

The second tier of pitchers (Burnes, Sale, Kirby, DeGrom, Cease, Snell) is evaluated, considering their ADP, projected performance, and injury concerns. The risks and rewards of selecting these pitchers are weighed.

00:55:57
Tier 3 Pitcher Analysis: Solid Starters

The third tier (Yamamoto, Cole, King, Lopez, Valdez) is analyzed, focusing on projected innings, stuff, command, and injury history. The trade-offs between high-ceiling and high-floor pitchers are discussed.

01:04:46
Tier 4 Pitcher Analysis & Key Takeaways

A brief discussion of the final tier of pitchers is followed by a summary of key takeaways, reiterating the importance of considering health and injury risk when drafting.

01:07:22
Bryce Miller Deep Dive & Early Round Considerations

Bryce Miller's potential is analyzed, comparing him to Ober and Shota. Concerns about his home run rate and suitability for a high draft pick are addressed.

01:11:16
Mid-Round Pitcher Analysis: Nola, Castillo, Brown

Mid-round pitchers (Nola, Castillo, Brown) are analyzed, considering their strengths, weaknesses, and potential risks based on age, health, and pitch effectiveness.

01:15:11
High-Ceiling, High-Risk Pitchers: Sasaki & Green

High-ceiling pitchers Roki Sasaki and Hunter Green are discussed, weighing their potential upside against injury concerns and innings limitations.

01:19:41
Late-Round Sleepers & Reliable Options

Late-round sleeper Spencer Schwellenbach and reliable option Tanner Bibee are analyzed, highlighting their potential value and strengths/weaknesses.

Keywords

Average Draft Position (ADP)


A statistic representing the average draft pick number of a player.

Stuff+


A baseball statistic measuring a pitcher's stuff (velocity, movement).

Injury Risk


The likelihood of a player sustaining an injury impacting performance.

Fantasy Baseball Draft Strategy


The approach used to select players in a fantasy baseball draft.

Pitch Arsenal


The variety of pitches a pitcher throws.

Velocity


The speed of a pitcher's fastball.

Swinging Strike Rate


Percentage of pitches swung at and missed.

Home Run Rate


Frequency with which a pitcher allows home runs.

Innings Projection


Prediction of the number of innings a pitcher is expected to throw.

Command


A pitcher's ability to consistently throw pitches where intended.

Q&A

  • What are the key factors to consider when drafting pitchers in fantasy baseball?

    Key factors include ADP, Stuff+, projected innings, injury risk, pitch arsenal, velocity, swinging strike rate, and command.

  • How do the hosts assess the injury risk of pitchers?

    They use historical and recent injury data and qualitative assessments based on pitching mechanics and workload.

  • Which pitchers are considered high-risk, high-reward options?

    Garrett Crochet and Jacob deGrom are highlighted as high-risk, high-reward options.

  • What is the hosts' overall draft strategy regarding pitchers?

    A more conservative approach in early rounds, prioritizing lower injury risk, with high-upside pitchers in later rounds.

  • How does a pitcher's home park affect their fantasy value?

    A hitter-friendly park negatively impacts a pitcher's fantasy value due to higher home run rates.

  • How does the development of a pitcher's pitch arsenal impact their fantasy value?

    Adding new effective pitches increases versatility and effectiveness, potentially leading to higher strikeout rates and lower WHIP.

  • Which pitchers represent the best value in their respective draft ranges?

    Bryce Miller, Aaron Nola, and Spencer Schwellenbach are suggested as potential value picks.

  • What are the potential risks associated with drafting high-ceiling pitchers?

    High-ceiling pitchers often carry higher injury risk and may have innings limitations.

Show Notes

Eno and DVR begin Pitcher Week with the first installment of the 2025 Starting Pitcher Preview! This episode focuses on the starting pitchers often drafted among the Top 100 Overall in early fantasy baseball drafts. Should you build your roster around Paul Skenes or Tarik Skubal and take a pitcher in Round 1, or wait a couple of rounds and find a potentially undervalued ace? How much will the Dodgers' use of a six-man rotation impact the value of their top-end starters? And which risers still have another level they could reach in the upcoming season?


Rundown

2:19 ADP Tier 1a -- Paul Skenes v. Tarik Skubal in Round 1!

12:37 ADP Tier 1a -- Zack Wheeler, Logan Gilbert & Garrett Crochet

25:21 ADP Tier 1b -- Corbin Burnes, Chris Sale & Jacob deGrom,

40:22 ADP Tier 1b -- George Kirby, Cole Ragans, Dylan Cease & Blake Snell

55:55 ADP Tier 2 -- Yoshinobu Yamamoto, Gerrit Cole, Michael King, Pablo López & Framber Valdez

1:05:32 ADP Tier 3 -- Shota Imanaga, Bryce Miller, Bailey Ober, Aaron Nola, Luis Castillo, Hunter Greene, Roki Sasaki, Spencer Schwellenbach & Tanner Bibee


Follow Eno on Bluesky: @enosarris.bsky.social

Follow DVR on Bluesky: @dvr.bsky.social

e-mail: ratesandbarrels@gmail.com


Join our Discord: https://discord.gg/FyBa9f3wFe

Share your Positional Rankings in the HiveMind Ranks for Starting Pitchers: https://forms.gle/QhdU1UimnejRG1bP6

Subscribe to The Athletic: theathletic.com/ratesandbarrels


Hosts: Derek VanRiper & Eno Sarris

Producer Brian Smith

Executive Producer: Derek VanRiper

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Comments 
In Channel
loading

Table of contents

00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

2025 Starting Pitcher Preview, Part 1

2025 Starting Pitcher Preview, Part 1

The Athletic