DiscoverRates & Barrels: A show about Baseball2025 Starting Pitcher Preview, Part 2
2025 Starting Pitcher Preview, Part 2

2025 Starting Pitcher Preview, Part 2

Update: 2025-01-29
Share

Digest

This fantasy baseball podcast episode delves into evaluating pitchers projected in the 100-200 pick range for fantasy drafts. The hosts discuss various pitchers, analyzing their strengths and weaknesses, including injury risk, pitch arsenals, and potential for improvement. Specific players discussed include Freddie Peralta, Logan Webb, Max Fried, Joe Ryan, Tyler Glasnow, Grayson Rodriguez, Hunter Brown, Sonny Gray, Shane McClanahan, Zach Gallen, Carlos Rodón, Justin Steele, Spencer Strider, Brian Wood, Jack Flaherty, Kodai Senga, Jared Jones, Robbie Ray, Sandy Alcantara, Ronaldo Lopez, Yusuke Kucchi, and Kevin Gausman. The discussion also covers broader strategic considerations, such as the impact of changing pitcher workloads, the importance of park factors, and the value of in-season acquisitions and trades. The hosts emphasize the need to balance a pitcher's potential with their injury risk and highlight the use of advanced metrics like Stuff+ to assess raw talent. The episode concludes with a discussion of the Atlanta Braves' pitching rotation and overall draft strategies.

Outlines

00:03:02
Fantasy Baseball Pitcher Preview: Picks 100-200 & Key Evaluation Factors

Introduces the discussion of fantasy baseball pitchers in the 100-200 pick range, emphasizing tiers, potential for improvement/decline, and the impact of injuries (like Roki Sasaki's). Analyzes Peralta and Webb, highlighting their strengths, weaknesses, and risk factors.

00:12:28
Logan Webb, Max Fried, Joe Ryan, and Injury Risk Analysis

Continues the analysis of Logan Webb, focusing on his strikeout potential and comparison to relievers. Analyzes Max Fried's move to the Yankees and its impact, and discusses Joe Ryan's injury history and potential.

00:23:57
Tyler Glasnow, Lower Volume Pitchers, and the New Era of Pitching

Discusses Tyler Glasnow's high ceiling and injury risk, followed by a discussion of the changing landscape of pitcher workloads and the importance of skills over innings.

00:31:26
Grayson Rodriguez, Hunter Brown, Sonny Gray, and Shane McClanahan

Analyzes Grayson Rodriguez's potential and pitch arsenal, followed by a discussion of Hunter Brown's late-season performance, Sonny Gray's age-related discount, and Shane McClanahan's recovery from Tommy John surgery.

00:45:43
Zach Gallen, Carlos Rodón, Tier 4B Pitchers, and Injury Risk

Analyzes Zach Gallen's velocity decline and potential rebound, followed by a discussion of Tier 4B pitchers (including Rodón, Steele, Strider, Wood, Flaherty, and Senga) and their common injury risk.

01:11:56
Jared Jones, Robbie Ray, Sandy Alcantara, and Other Pitcher Analyses

Detailed analysis of Jared Jones's potential, followed by discussions of Robbie Ray (comparing him to Rodón), Sandy Alcantara's post-surgery performance, and Ronaldo Lopez's surprising success.

01:22:57
Atlanta Braves Rotation, Draft Strategy, and Specific Pitcher Deep Dives

Discussion of the Atlanta Braves' pitching rotation, fantasy draft strategies (emphasizing trades and in-season acquisitions), and detailed analyses of Yusuke Kucchi and Kevin Gausman.

Keywords

Fantasy Baseball Pitcher Rankings


A list of baseball pitchers ranked by projected fantasy value, considering ERA, WHIP, strikeouts, and innings pitched.

Pitch Arsenal


A pitcher's collection of pitches, including types, velocity, and movement.

Injury Risk


The likelihood of a pitcher sustaining an injury impacting performance or availability.

Stuff+


A baseball statistic measuring a pitcher's raw stuff, independent of context.

Park Factor


A statistic adjusting pitching performance based on ballpark characteristics.

Innings Projection


A prediction of the number of innings a pitcher is expected to pitch.

Tommy John Surgery


A surgical procedure to repair a torn ulnar collateral ligament (UCL).

Pitch Mix


The variety and usage of different pitches a pitcher throws.

ERA (Earned Run Average)


A statistic measuring a pitcher's effectiveness by calculating the average number of earned runs they allow per nine innings pitched.

WHIP (Walks plus Hits per Inning Pitched)


A statistic measuring a pitcher's ability to prevent runners from reaching base.

Q&A

  • What are the key factors to consider when evaluating pitchers in the 100-200 pick range of fantasy baseball drafts?

    Key factors include projected innings pitched, strikeout rate, ERA, WHIP, injury history, and the impact of park factors. Pitch arsenal and pitching mechanics also play a significant role.

  • How does the evolving landscape of pitcher workloads impact fantasy baseball strategy?

    Recent Cy Young winners have demonstrated success with lower innings totals, suggesting that focusing solely on high innings projections may not be the optimal strategy. Skills and ratios become more important.

  • How do you assess the risk versus reward of drafting pitchers with significant injury histories?

    It's a careful balancing act. Consider the pitcher's talent level and potential upside against the likelihood of injury impacting their availability and performance. Spring training updates are crucial.

  • What is the significance of "Stuff+" in evaluating pitchers?

    Stuff+ provides a measure of a pitcher's raw talent, independent of external factors like park effects or run support. It helps identify pitchers with high potential even if their overall stats are currently lower.

  • How do park factors influence pitcher rankings and draft decisions?

    Hitter-friendly parks can inflate a pitcher's ERA and WHIP, while pitcher-friendly parks can lead to better stats. It's essential to adjust projections based on the park where a pitcher plays.

  • What are the key factors to consider when evaluating Jared Jones's fantasy value?

    His pitch mix, command, projected innings, and the potential for improvement in his secondary pitches are crucial. His inexperience and predictability are potential downsides.

  • How does the risk of Tommy John surgery impact the evaluation of pitchers like Robbie Ray and Sandy Alcantara?

    Tommy John surgery carries significant risk, impacting projected innings and overall performance. The proximity to the surgery and the pitcher's history influence the assessment of their fantasy value.

  • What are some effective strategies for building a successful fantasy baseball team beyond the draft?

    Actively participating in trades and utilizing in-season free agency to acquire players and address roster needs is crucial for long-term success.

  • How much weight should be given to a pitcher's past performance when projecting their future success?

    Past performance is a valuable indicator, but it's essential to consider factors like age, injury history, pitch mix changes, and underlying statistical trends to make accurate projections. Recent performance is often more indicative of future performance than older data.

Show Notes

Eno and DVR continue Pitcher Week with the second installment of the 2025 Starting Pitcher Preview! This episode focuses on the starting pitchers often drafted between Pick 100 and 200 overall in early fantasy baseball drafts. Which fallers from previous seasons offer the most rebound potential? Where should you take on injury risk in this group? And, is there any good oatmeal available for your pitching staff within these tiers?


Rundown

2:47 ADP Tier 4a -- Freddy Peralta, Logan Webb & Max Fried

18:42 ADP Tier 4a (continued -- Joe Ryan, Tyler Glasnow, Grayson Rodriguez & Hunter Brown

37:47 ADP Tier 4a (continued) -- Sonny Gray, Shane McClanahan & Zac Gallen

49:18  ADP Tier 4b -- Carlos Rodón, Justin Steele, Spencer Strider, Bryan Woo, Jack Flaherty, Kodai Senga

1:11:40 ADP Tier 5a-- Jared Jones, Robbie Ray, Sandy Alcantara, Reynaldo López, Yusei Kikiuchi & Kevin Gausman


Follow Eno on Bluesky: @enosarris.bsky.social

Follow DVR on Bluesky: @dvr.bsky.social

e-mail: ratesandbarrels@gmail.com


Join our Discord: https://discord.gg/FyBa9f3wFe

Share your Positional Rankings in the HiveMind Ranks for Starting Pitchers: https://forms.gle/QhdU1UimnejRG1bP6

Subscribe to The Athletic: theathletic.com/ratesandbarrels


Hosts: Derek VanRiper & Eno Sarris

Producer Brian Smith

Executive Producer: Derek VanRiper

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Comments 
In Channel
loading

Table of contents

00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

2025 Starting Pitcher Preview, Part 2

2025 Starting Pitcher Preview, Part 2

The Athletic