AFC QB supporting cast rankings
1Digest
This podcast analyzes and ranks the supporting casts of AFC teams, then expands to rank the top NFL offenses. Three key criteria are used: offensive infrastructure (including play-calling), pass-catching talent, and offensive line/run game. The hosts debate the rankings of teams like the Jets (lowest ranked), Jaguars (high ceiling but concerns), and Bills (debated due to receiving corps). The discussion highlights the importance of a strong offensive line, effective play-calling, and a cohesive offensive unit. Ultimately, the Ravens are ranked as the top NFL offense due to Lamar Jackson's performance, a strong running game, and elite receiving talent. The podcast emphasizes the interconnectedness of the offensive ecosystem and the impact of coaching decisions.
Outlines
Introduction and AFC Supporting Cast Ranking (Parts 1-4)
The podcast introduces the criteria for ranking AFC teams' supporting casts (offensive infrastructure, pass-catching talent, and offensive line/run game) and then proceeds to rank all AFC teams from worst to best, discussing individual players and team strengths/weaknesses.
Top 5 NFL Offenses and Re-ranking Justification
The hosts initially rank their top five NFL offenses, sparking debate, particularly regarding the Bills' receiving corps. They adjust rankings, emphasizing the Broncos' strong offensive line and Sean Payton's coaching impact, and discuss the importance of a cohesive offensive unit and play-calling.
Broncos, Bengals, and Ravens Analysis
A deeper dive into the Broncos' and Bengals' offensive strengths, highlighting the Bengals' wide receivers and the Broncos' pass protection and coaching. The Ravens are ultimately declared the number one offense due to Lamar Jackson, their running back, receiving corps, and Todd Monken's play-calling.
Full NFL Offense Rankings and Discussion
The podcast concludes by revealing the complete NFL offense rankings (1-16), revisiting reasoning for specific team placements, particularly those in the AFC South, and acknowledging potential areas of future adjustment.
Keywords
Supporting Cast (NFL)
The players on a team besides the quarterback, crucial for overall team success. Factors include offensive line, receivers, running backs, and tight ends.
Offensive Ecosystem
The interconnectedness of an NFL team's offensive units (line, receivers, running backs, play-calling). A well-functioning ecosystem maximizes player potential.
Play-Caller
The individual responsible for designing and calling offensive plays. A skilled play-caller adapts strategies to player strengths.
AFC (American Football Conference)
One of the two conferences in the NFL. Teams in the AFC compete for playoff spots and the Super Bowl.
Offensive Line
The five offensive linemen protecting the quarterback and opening running lanes. A strong offensive line is fundamental to a successful offense.
Pass-Catching Talent
The skill and ability of receivers and tight ends to catch passes. Impacts the effectiveness of the passing game.
Run Game Efficiency
How effectively a team runs the ball, considering yards gained per carry and contribution to the offense.
Play-Calling
The strategic decision-making process of choosing plays. Effective play-calling maximizes offensive potential.
Pass Catchers
Players whose primary role is to catch passes (wide receivers, tight ends, running backs).
EPA per Target
Expected Points Added per target; a valuable advanced statistic measuring a player's impact on expected points.
Q&A
What are the three main factors considered when ranking AFC supporting casts?
Offensive infrastructure/play-caller, pass-catching talent, and offensive line/run game.
Which AFC team had the lowest-ranked supporting cast?
The New York Jets.
How did the hosts' differing perspectives influence their rankings?
One host prioritized potential upside, the other emphasized proven talent, leading to discrepancies.
What role did the offensive line play in the rankings?
A strong offensive line was crucial for higher rankings; uncertainty impacted rankings.
Which team was considered to have the highest ceiling?
The Jacksonville Jaguars.
What are key factors differentiating top-tier NFL offenses?
Strong offensive lines, elite quarterbacks, talented pass catchers, effective run games, and innovative play-calling.
How much weight should be given to coaching staff?
Significant impact; a skilled play-caller maximizes potential, but talent remains crucial.
Which team's ranking was most debated?
The Buffalo Bills, due to uncertainty about their receiving corps.
What is the overall consensus on the Ravens' offensive ranking?
Ranked number one due to strong performance, running game, receiving corps, and play-calling.
Show Notes
The NFL is a quarterback driven league, there's no doubt about it. But do the Eagles win the Super Bowl last year without their offensive line? Do the Chiefs establish a dynasty without Andy Reid? Are the Rams and Bengals playing in Super Bowl LVI without Cooper Kupp, Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins? The supporting casts around quarterbacks matter, too. Robert Mays and Derrik Klassen rank the supporting casts in the AFC on this episode of The Athletic Football Show.
Rundown (timestamps are approximate)
1:25 Intro
7:10 Jets
11:02 Patriots
15:06 Browns
18:56 Titans
22:23 Texans
29:21 Chargers
34:34 Steelers
38:32 Jaguars
43:06 Dolphins
48:43 Raiders
54:00 Colts
59:01 Chiefs
1:04:42 Bills
1:08:50 Broncos
1:09:46 Bengals
1:12:46 Back to the Broncos!
1:16:17 Ravens
Hosts: Robert Mays and Derrik Klassen
Executive Producer: Michael Beller
Producer: Michael Beller
Subscribe to The Athletic Football Show...
Follow Robert on Bluesky: @robertmays.bsky.social
Follow Derrik on Bluesky: @qbklass.bsky.social
Follow Robert on X: @robertmays
Follow Derrik on X: @QBKlass
Theme song: Haunted
Written by Dylan Slocum, Trevor Dietrich, Ruben Duarte, Kyle McAulay, and Meredith VanWoert / Performed by Spanish Love Songs
Courtesy of Pure Noise / By arrangement with Bank Robber Music, LLC
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Table of contents
United States
