CNLP 704 | The Dismal State of Evangelism, the Divide Between Church and Culture, and The Missed Opportunity of Unchurched People's Surprising Spiritual Openness with David Kinnaman and Mark Matlock
Digest
This podcast features David Kinnaman and Mark Matlock discussing the Barna Group's research on spiritual openness in America. Despite perceived cultural hostility, a significant portion of the population, especially younger generations, exhibits spiritual curiosity. The conversation challenges traditional evangelism methods, advocating for a relational approach focused on building genuine connections and understanding rather than immediate conversions. The podcast highlights the importance of addressing the "need for closure" in individuals and suggests practical changes to weekend services, such as incorporating lay testimonies and diverse traditions. A new apologetic approach emphasizing peace and relationship with Jesus is proposed, moving beyond solely doctrinal certainty. The speakers stress the value of diverse perspectives and recommend Mark Matlock's book, "Faith for the Curious," and Barna's "State of the Church 2025" initiative for further resources and insights into navigating current church trends. The podcast concludes with a preview of future episodes and a call to action for listeners.
Outlines
Introduction: Evangelism in Modern America
Introduces the podcast and previews a discussion on the state of evangelism and spiritual openness in America, featuring David Kinnaman and Mark Matlock. This includes an overview of the Barna Group's research and the challenges facing modern evangelism.
Challenges of Modern Evangelism
Discusses the challenges of evangelism in the modern church, including the divide between church and culture and missed opportunities to connect with spiritually open individuals. This section explores the disconnect between perceived cultural hostility and the reality of widespread spiritual openness.
Spiritual Openness in America: Barna Group Research
Introduces David Kinnaman and Mark Matlock and highlights their expertise and the Barna Group's research on spiritual openness. Focuses on the surprising level of spiritual openness in the US, especially among younger generations.
Spiritual Openness and Cultural Narratives
Explores the contrast between perceived cultural hostility and high levels of spiritual openness. Discusses the motivations behind negative narratives within the church and their impact on evangelism.
Open vs. Closed Mindsets in the Church
Analyzes research on "need for closure" and its correlation with spiritual openness. Uses the analogy of Buzz and Woody from Toy Story to illustrate the difference between open and closed mindsets within the church.
Bridging the Gap: New Evangelism Approaches
Addresses the challenge of bridging the gap between traditional evangelism and the spiritual openness of the current culture. Emphasizes the need for a shift in approach, focusing on relationship-building and genuine curiosity. Includes practical suggestions for engaging with spiritually curious individuals.
Mental Health, A New Apologetic, and Practical Church Adjustments
Connects spiritual openness with mental health, suggesting a new apologetic approach focused on peace and relationship with Jesus. Discusses practical adjustments to weekend church services to better engage spiritually curious individuals, including incorporating lay testimonies and diverse traditions.
Resources and Next Steps
Promotes Mark Matlock's new book, "Faith for the Curious," and Barna's "State of the Church 2025" initiative. Includes a podcast wrap-up, a call to action, and a preview of the next episode. Also highlights the 2025 church trends report.
Keywords
Spiritual Openness
The willingness to consider spiritual or religious beliefs and experiences, even if one doesn't identify with a specific religion. Barna Group research indicates high levels in the US, particularly among younger generations.
Evangelism
The practice of sharing the Christian faith. The podcast discusses the need for new approaches to evangelism that are more relational and less focused on immediate conversions.
Need for Closure
A personality trait reflecting a preference for certainty and a low tolerance for ambiguity. Research shows practicing Christians often have a higher need for closure than non-Christians.
Spiritual Curiosity
A desire to explore spiritual and religious matters, often without a commitment to a specific faith. The podcast emphasizes engaging with spiritually curious individuals through genuine relationship and listening.
Authentic Evangelism
Sharing one's faith in a genuine and relational way, focusing on building relationships and fostering trust rather than forcing conversions.
Church Trends 2025
Analysis of significant shifts and challenges facing churches in 2025. Includes topics like evangelism, Gen Z engagement, mental health, and innovative church models. Provides data-driven insights for strategic planning.
State of the Church 2025
A Barna Group initiative providing research and resources to help church leaders understand and respond to current trends shaping the church landscape. Focuses on building flourishing people and thriving churches.
Faith for the Curious
A book exploring faith from a perspective of curiosity and openness to diverse viewpoints. Promotes engaging with different perspectives and expanding one's understanding of faith.
Barna Group
A research organization providing data and insights on faith and culture in America. Their research is central to the podcast's discussion on spiritual openness and evangelism.
Q&A
What is the Barna Group's research revealing about spiritual openness in America?
Barna research shows a surprising level of spiritual openness, especially among younger generations. A significant percentage of Americans identify as spiritual, believe in a supernatural world, and are open to exploring different spiritual paths.
How can churches better engage with spiritually curious individuals?
Churches should shift from a transactional approach to evangelism to a relational one. This involves fostering genuine curiosity about individuals' lives, integrating lay testimonies, creating safe spaces for exploration, and emphasizing relationship with Jesus over doctrinal certainty.
What are some practical changes churches can make to their weekend services?
Incorporate more lay testimonies, integrate diverse traditions, create a welcoming and hospitable environment, and focus on sharing personal stories of faith and how Jesus has impacted lives.
Why is a new apologetic approach needed in today's culture?
Traditional apologetics, rooted in rationalism and the Enlightenment, are less effective in a culture where people are not necessarily walking away from faith but seeking deeper meaning and spiritual experiences. A new approach should emphasize relationship, trust, and addressing the needs and questions of spiritually curious individuals.
What is one practical step pastors can take to engage with the spiritually open culture?
Cultivate genuine curiosity about the lives of others without an immediate agenda to convert them. This involves building relationships and creating spaces for authentic connection outside of traditional church settings.
How can church leaders effectively navigate the changing cultural landscape?
By staying informed about current trends and utilizing resources like the "State of the Church 2025" initiative and the annual church trends report. This allows for data-driven decision-making and adapting ministry strategies accordingly.
Where can I find more information about the 2025 church trends and the State of the Church initiative?
The 2025 church trends report is available at [relevant website - replace bracketed information with actual website address if available]. Information on the State of the Church initiative can be found at [relevant website - replace bracketed information with actual website address if available].
Show Notes
Only 1% of pastors say their churches are very effective at evangelism. Yet, 72% of people say they are open spiritually.
In this episode, Barna CEO David Kinnaman and author Mark Matlock continue the 2025 Church Trends series and discuss the current divide between church and culture, the surprisingly dismal state of evangelism in the church today, and the missed opportunity of unchurched people's surprising spiritual openness.
☕️ 2025 Church Trends Leader Guide
🧠 The Art of Leadership Academy
Follow @careynieuwhof
Follow @theartofleadershipnetwork
DOWNLOAD FOR FREE:
2025 Church Trends Leader Guide
Highly Productive Leader Challenge
On February 3rd, I'm kicking off a 4-Week Highly Productive Leader Challenge designed specifically for leaders like you who feel stuck in the cycle of overwhelm.
Learn more at Productive2025.com
In a free 60-minute webinar, Mark Clark, pastor at Bayside Church, will share the 5 essential traits that define truly great leaders.
Register at thriveconference.org/
Gloo gives you 10,000 texts and 3 groups for free every month. That's right—no cost, no strings attached.
So why wait? Sign up for Gloo today at gloo.us/freetexting.
Brought to you by The Art of Leadership Network
Table of contents
United States
