DELPHI MURDERS: EERIE "RITUAL" SACRIFICE-MURDER CLAIMS, CLASH OVER SUSPECT "CONFESSIONS"
Digest
This podcast episode delves into the complex legal battles surrounding the Delphine Murders, the double homicide of Abigail Williams and Liberty German in Delphi, Indiana. The episode focuses on the alleged confessions made by Richard Allen, the suspect, to his wife, mother, and a prison doctor. The episode explores the legal arguments surrounding the admissibility of these confessions and the defense's attempts to suppress them. The episode also examines the gruesome details of the murders, including the use of sharp force injury and potential mutilation. The episode highlights the significance of the video recorded by Liberty German, which captured the suspect on the bridge, and discusses the defense's attempts to suppress this video. The episode analyzes the suspect's unsettling behavior in the courtroom, suggesting that his creepy demeanor could be detrimental to his defense. The episode also discusses the strong evidence against him, including ballistics evidence and the suspect's own admissions. The episode examines the defense's shifting theories, which now include claims that a white nationalist group was responsible for the murders. The episode also discusses the defense's request to transfer the suspect from the prison facility due to alleged threats from members of the white nationalist group. The episode focuses on the hard evidence against the suspect, including the handgun found in his home and the matching bullet found at the crime scene. The episode also highlights the suspect's inconsistent story about being on the bridge "watching the fish." The episode discusses the state's strong evidence, including the suspect's voice on Libby's video and the potential DNA evidence on his jacket. The episode also explores the defense's counterarguments and their attempts to create reasonable doubt.
Outlines
The Delphine Murders: Confessions, Evidence, and Shifting Theories
This episode explores the legal battles surrounding the Delphine Murders, focusing on the alleged confessions of Richard Allen, the suspect, and the defense's theory that Odinists were responsible for the murders. The episode also delves into the gruesome details of the murders and the significance of Libby's cell phone video.
Legal Battles Over Confessions and Evidence
This chapter delves into the legal battles surrounding the alleged confessions made by Richard Allen to his wife, mother, and a prison doctor. The episode discusses the admissibility of these confessions and the defense's attempts to suppress them.
The Suspect's Behavior and the Evidence Against Him
This chapter explores the gruesome details of the murders, including the use of sharp force injury and potential mutilation. The episode also discusses the suspect's unsettling behavior in the courtroom, including his menacing stares at the victims' families. The episode highlights the significance of Libby's cell phone video and the strong evidence against him, including ballistics evidence and the suspect's own admissions.
Shifting Theories and the Suspect's Transfer Request
This chapter examines the defense's shifting theories, which now include claims that a white nationalist group was responsible for the murders. The episode also discusses the defense's request to transfer the suspect from the prison facility due to alleged threats from members of the white nationalist group.
Hard Evidence and the Suspect's Inconsistent Story
This chapter focuses on the hard evidence against the suspect, including the handgun found in his home and the matching bullet found at the crime scene. The episode also highlights the suspect's inconsistent story about being on the bridge "watching the fish."
The State's Case and the Defense's Counterarguments
This chapter discusses the state's strong evidence, including the suspect's voice on Libby's video and the potential DNA evidence on his jacket. The episode also explores the defense's counterarguments and their attempts to create reasonable doubt.
Keywords
Delphine Murders
The Delphine Murders refers to the double homicide of Abigail Williams and Liberty German, two teenage girls who were murdered in Delphi, Indiana, in 2017. The case has garnered national attention due to the gruesome nature of the crime and the ongoing investigation.
Richard Allen
Richard Allen is the suspect in the Delphine Murders. He is a local pharmacy technician who was arrested in 2023. Allen has pleaded not guilty to the charges against him.
Libby's Cell Phone Video
Liberty German, one of the victims, recorded a video on her cell phone that captured the suspect on the bridge. This video is considered crucial evidence in the case and has been the subject of much legal debate.
Ballistics Evidence
Ballistics evidence refers to the analysis of firearms and ammunition. In the Delphine Murders case, ballistics evidence has linked the handgun found in the suspect's home to the bullet found at the crime scene.
Odinism
Odinism is a modern pagan religion that draws inspiration from Norse mythology. It is a polytheistic religion that worships the Norse gods, including Odin, Thor, and the Valkyries. The defense in the Delphine Murders case has claimed that Odinists were responsible for the murders.
White Nationalist Group
The defense has recently claimed that a white nationalist group was responsible for the murders. This theory is based on the alleged motive of the group, which is related to the victims' parents' interracial relationship.
Q&A
What are the main legal battles surrounding the alleged confessions made by Richard Allen?
The main legal battles revolve around the admissibility of Allen's alleged confessions to his wife, mother, and a prison doctor. The defense is trying to suppress these confessions, arguing that they were made under duress or that they are protected by spousal privilege.
What is the significance of Libby's cell phone video?
Libby's video is crucial evidence because it captured the suspect on the bridge. The defense is trying to suppress this video, arguing that it was handed over too late in the discovery process. However, the prosecution believes that the video will be instrumental in convicting Allen if he is guilty.
What is the defense's current theory about the murders?
The defense has shifted its theory several times, now claiming that a white nationalist group was responsible for the murders. They argue that the group had a motive because the victims' parents were in an interracial relationship. However, the prosecution believes that this theory is weak and lacks sufficient evidence.
Show Notes
Special Judge Frances Gull is hearing arguments on several motions in the Delphi Murders trial of Richard Allen. The judge will consider six topics: Richard Allen's safekeeping, psychologist statements, suppression of some of Richard Allen's previous statements, discovery issues that continue to plague the case, a defense request to dismiss the case, and what both sides can say in front of jurors without specific permission from the judge.
The defense seeks four sanctions. They want the court to inform jurors that the prosecution violated rules by delaying the turnover of exculpatory evidence. They also want the judge to allow the defense to play any video that was "belatedly produced" without state objection. Additionally, the defense aims to prevent the state from rebutting evidence provided by former Rushville police chief Todd Click on May 1, 2023, and they want to bar the prosecution from using any data or information from Liberty German's phone in evidentiary presentations.
The state wants to limit what the defense can mention in front of jurors without prior approval from the judge. Prosecutors have several pages of items they seek to restrict, including personal attacks on the prosecutor and any attempt to introduce evidence of third-party motive that is not relevant or would unfairly prejudice jurors.
This includes mentions of Odinism, ritualistic killings, names of others the defense might claim are connected to the killings, geofencing, references to how discovery was handled, and any mention of an investigation conducted by former Rushville Police Chief Todd Click.
JOINING NANCY GRACE TODAY:
- Rich Shoenstein - Trial Attorney, Partner with Tarter Krinsky & Drogin; X:@LawfulRiches
- Caryn L. Stark – Psychologist, Renowned TV and Radio Trauma Expert and Consultant; Instagram: carynpsych/FB: Caryn Stark Private Practice
- Chris McDonough – Director At the Cold Case Foundation, Former Homicide Detective; Host of YouTube channel: “The Interview Room”
- Joseph Scott Morgan – Professor of Forensics: Jacksonville State University, and Author: "Blood Beneath My Feet,” and Host: “Body Bags with Joseph Scott Morgan;” Twitter/X: @JoScottForensic
- Susan Hendricks - Journalist, Author of “Down the Hill: My Descent into the Double Murder in Delphi;" IG @susan_hendricks, X @SusanHendicks
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Table of contents
United States
