DiscoverPop PantheonELTON JOHN: PART 2 (with Rolling Stone's Rob Sheffield)
ELTON JOHN: PART 2 (with Rolling Stone's Rob Sheffield)

ELTON JOHN: PART 2 (with Rolling Stone's Rob Sheffield)

Update: 2025-06-19
Share

Digest

This Pop Pantheon podcast episode delves into the multifaceted career of Elton John, focusing on the period after his monumental success with *Goodbye Yellow Brick Road*. The discussion analyzes his continued chart success with albums like *Caribou*, *Captain Fantastic and the Brown Dirt Cowboy*, and *Rock of the Westies*, acknowledging the mixed reception of later albums such as *Blue Moves*. The episode explores the impact of Elton's coming out in 1976 on his career and creative choices. His 1980s comeback, fueled by albums like *Jump Up* and *Too Low for Zero* (featuring hits like "I'm Still Standing" and "I Guess That's Why They Call It the Blues"), is examined, acknowledging the influence of cocaine on his creative process during this period. The podcast also discusses his successful transition into musical theater with *The Lion King* and the enduring impact of "Can You Feel the Love Tonight." Finally, the episode explores Elton's later career, his collaborations, his evolution into a brand, and his lasting legacy on popular music and culture. The podcast also includes an announcement for an upcoming Pop Girls Summer party. Listeners are encouraged to submit unpopular pop opinions for a future episode.

Outlines

00:00:00
Pop Pantheon Intro & Elton John's Post-1974 Career

Introduces the Pop Pantheon podcast and announces an upcoming event. Analyzes Elton John's career after *Goodbye Yellow Brick Road*, covering his continued success, the impact of his coming out, and the mixed reception of later albums like *Blue Moves*.

00:33:56
Analyzing Elton John's Classic & Post-Classic Albums

Deep dive into Elton John's *Captain Fantastic and the Brown Dirt Cowboy*, *Rock of the Westies*, and *Blue Moves*, focusing on musical styles, lyrical content, critical reception, and the shift in his career trajectory. Also covers his post-"classic period" career, collaborations, continued success, and lasting impact.

01:00:21
Elton John's 1980s Comeback and Prolific Output

Analyzes Elton John's 1980s comeback, starting with *Jump Up* and its experimental nature, followed by the triumph of *Too Low for Zero*. Examines his prolific output throughout the decade, acknowledging the influence of cocaine and highlighting notable hits.

01:22:49
The Lion King, Musical Theater, and Elton's Later Career

Explores Elton John's collaboration on *The Lion King*, his transition into musical theater, and the impact of "Can You Feel the Love Tonight." Examines his later career, collaborations, brand evolution, and enduring legacy, including albums like *Duets* and *Peachtree Road*.

Keywords

Elton John


Legendary British singer-songwriter known for his flamboyant style, prolific output, and enduring influence on pop music.

Pop Pantheon


A podcast dedicated to in-depth analysis and ranking of pop stars.

Goodbye Yellow Brick Road


Elton John's 1973 album, a landmark achievement marking a peak of his early success.

Blue Moves


Elton John's 1976 double album, receiving mixed reviews and marking a turning point in his career.

Too Low for Zero


Elton John's comeback album, blending pop, rock, and new wave.

I'm Still Standing


Iconic Elton John song representing his triumphant comeback.

Can You Feel the Love Tonight


Song from *The Lion King*, showcasing his successful transition into musical theater.

Coming Out


Elton John's public disclosure of his sexual orientation.

The Lion King


Musical theater collaboration showcasing Elton John's versatility.

Q&A

  • What were the major creative and commercial challenges Elton John faced after his initial period of massive success?

    Elton faced pressure to maintain success, and his experimentation and coming out impacted his commercial trajectory.

  • How did Elton John's coming out in 1976 impact his career and public perception?

    Initially leading to a decline in commercial success, it ultimately solidified his status as a trailblazer in the LGBTQ+ community.

  • How does Elton John's later work compare to his earlier, more commercially successful albums?

    While less commercially successful, his later work showcases artistic evolution and experimentation.

  • How did Elton John's musical style evolve throughout the 1980s?

    He experimented with new wave and synth-pop, resulting in both successful and less successful songs.

  • What is the significance of "Empty Garden" in Elton John's career?

    It demonstrated his ability to connect with audiences through emotional vulnerability.

  • What is Elton John's lasting legacy in pop music?

    His musical innovation, emotional depth, embrace of his queer identity, and enduring influence on generations of pop stars.

  • What is the significance of Elton John's collaborations with other artists?

    They highlight his musical versatility and ability to transcend genre boundaries.

Show Notes

Rolling Stone’s Rob Sheffield returns to Pop Pantheon for the second and final part in our Elton John series. Rob and Louie pick up on Elton’s career after his initial run of hits in the 1970s at the tail end of his imperial phase. They then discuss his prolific career from 1975’s autobiographical Captain Fantastic to his poorly received disco record in 79, Victim of Love, and his comeback via 1983's Too Low for Zero. Next, they tackle later era Elton, from his Disney hits to his work on Broadway, 1997's re-recording of "Candle in the Wind" and his collabs with pop ingénues like Dua Lipa. Finally, they rank Elton John in The Official Pop Pantheon.

Listen to Pop Pantheon's Elton John Essentials Playlist

BUY TICKETS TO MAIN POP GIRLS: POP GIRL SUMMER ON 7/25 AT THE MEADOWS!


Gorgeous Gorgeous LA Pride on June 20 at Los Globos

Gorgeous Gorgeous NYC Pride on June 27 at Sultan Room

Join Pop Pantheon: All Access, Our Patreon Channel, for Exclusive Content and More

Shop Merch in Pop Pantheon's Store

Follow Pop Pantheon on Instagram

Follow DJ Louie XIV on Instagram

Follow DJ Louie XIV on Twitter

Join Pop Pantheon: All Access, Our Patreon Channel, for Exclusive Content and More


Shop Merch in Pop Pantheon's Store


Follow Pop Pantheon on Instagram


Follow DJ Louie XIV on Instagram


Follow Russ on Instagram


Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Comments 
In Channel
Hot 100 Dumpster Dive 2026

Hot 100 Dumpster Dive 2026

2026-04-3001:21:08

loading

Table of contents

00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

ELTON JOHN: PART 2 (with Rolling Stone's Rob Sheffield)

ELTON JOHN: PART 2 (with Rolling Stone's Rob Sheffield)