DiscoverCrime Stories with Nancy GraceGORGEOUS MOM DISAPPEARS AFTER FAMILY DINNER: WHAT HAPPENED TO MELISSA?
GORGEOUS MOM DISAPPEARS AFTER FAMILY DINNER: WHAT HAPPENED TO MELISSA?

GORGEOUS MOM DISAPPEARS AFTER FAMILY DINNER: WHAT HAPPENED TO MELISSA?

Update: 2024-08-07
Share

Digest

This podcast delves into the chilling case of Melissa Wolfenberger, a young mother who vanished after a family dinner in 2003. The episode features interviews with Melissa's heartbroken mother, Norma Patton, and sister, Tina Patton, who tirelessly sought answers about her disappearance. The family describes Melissa as a devoted mother who would never willingly leave her children, highlighting their disbelief and concern over her absence. The investigation takes a shocking turn with the discovery of a severed human skull in Atlanta, initially believed to be male. However, forensic analysis reveals the skull belongs to Melissa, confirming the grim reality of her fate. Suspicion falls upon Melissa's husband, Christopher Wolfenberger, whose inconsistent story and suspicious timing of his own disappearance raise red flags. The episode details the family's relentless pursuit of justice, facing skepticism and disbelief from authorities. The misidentification of the skull as male further delays the investigation, adding to their frustration. Forensic evidence reveals the brutality of the crime, highlighting the use of a mechanical saw to dismember Melissa's body. The podcast explores Christopher Wolfenberger's troubled past and the red flags that were missed by those close to Melissa. The episode emphasizes the logistical challenges and risks involved in disposing of a body, highlighting the perpetrator's calculated actions. The family shares their pain and frustration over Wolfenberger's manipulation of their children. After years of investigation, Christopher Wolfenberger is finally arrested for Melissa's murder. The episode highlights the family's relief and the importance of perseverance in seeking justice. The podcast concludes with reflections on the case, emphasizing the importance of thorough investigations, the impact of misidentification on families, and the need for never giving up on seeking justice for loved ones.

Outlines

00:00:00
Melissa Wolfenberger's Disappearance and the Family's Search for Answers

The episode introduces the case of Melissa Wolfenberger, a young mother who disappeared after a family dinner. The episode features interviews with Melissa's mother, Norma Patton, and sister, Tina Patton, who are determined to find out what happened to her. The family describes Melissa as a devoted mother who would never willingly leave her children, highlighting their disbelief and concern over her disappearance.

00:01:23
The Shocking Discovery and the Investigation's Turning Point

The episode details the discovery of a severed human skull in Atlanta, which initially leads investigators to believe it belongs to a male. The skull is later identified as Melissa's, revealing a shocking twist in the case. The episode explores the inconsistencies in Melissa's husband's account of her disappearance and the suspicious circumstances surrounding his own actions.

00:02:50
The Husband's Troubled Past and the Pursuit of Justice

The episode explores the red flags surrounding Melissa's husband, Christopher Wolfenberger, and the family's observations about his troubled past. The episode highlights the challenges faced by Melissa's family in seeking justice, including skepticism from authorities and the misidentification of the skull. The episode also details the forensic evidence found at the crime scene, emphasizing the brutality of the crime and the family's struggle to cope with the loss.

00:03:29
The Arrest and the Quest for Justice

The episode details the arrest of Christopher Wolfenberger for Melissa's murder after years of investigation. The episode highlights the family's relief and the importance of perseverance in seeking justice. The episode concludes with reflections on the case, emphasizing the importance of thorough investigations, the impact of misidentification on families, and the need for never giving up on seeking justice for loved ones.

Keywords

Melissa Wolfenberger


Melissa Wolfenberger was a young mother who disappeared in Atlanta, Georgia, in 2003. Her case remained unsolved for years until her skull was discovered and identified in 2018.

Christopher Wolfenberger


Christopher Wolfenberger was Melissa Wolfenberger's husband. He was initially considered a person of interest in her disappearance but was later arrested for her murder in 2018.

Cold Case


A cold case is a criminal investigation that has been inactive for a significant period of time. Cold cases often involve unsolved murders or missing persons cases.

Forensic Evidence


Forensic evidence is any physical evidence that is collected and analyzed in a criminal investigation. It can include fingerprints, DNA, bloodstains, and other traces of the crime.

Dismemberment


Dismemberment is the act of cutting or separating a body into parts. It is often used in cases of murder to conceal the body or make it more difficult to identify.

Misidentification


Misidentification occurs when a person or object is incorrectly identified. In the case of Melissa Wolfenberger, her skull was initially misidentified as belonging to a male.

Circumstantial Evidence


Circumstantial evidence is indirect evidence that suggests a person's involvement in a crime. It is often used in cases where there is no direct evidence of the crime.

Justice Delayed


Justice delayed refers to the situation where justice is not served promptly. In the case of Melissa Wolfenberger, justice was delayed for over 15 years.

Q&A

  • What were the initial circumstances surrounding Melissa Wolfenberger's disappearance?

    Melissa disappeared after a family dinner on Thanksgiving Day. She did not show up for Christmas or her mother's birthday, which was unusual for her.

  • Why did Melissa's family believe she would never have left her children?

    Melissa was a devoted mother who prioritized her children above all else. Her family described her as a loving and attentive parent who would never willingly abandon them.

  • What was the significance of the skull found in Atlanta?

    The skull was initially misidentified as belonging to a male, but it was later confirmed to be Melissa's. This discovery was a major turning point in the investigation and led to the eventual arrest of her husband.

  • What were some of the inconsistencies in Christopher Wolfenberger's account of Melissa's disappearance?

    Wolfenberger claimed Melissa left for California to start a new life, but he disappeared around the same time she did. He also claimed she broke his heart and he made no attempt to find her, which seemed suspicious.

  • What were some of the challenges faced by Melissa's family in seeking justice?

    The family faced skepticism and disbelief from authorities, who initially dismissed their concerns. The misidentification of the skull further delayed the investigation and added to their frustration.

  • What lessons can be learned from Melissa Wolfenberger's case?

    The case highlights the importance of thorough investigations, the impact of misidentification on families, and the need for perseverance in seeking justice. It also emphasizes the importance of recognizing red flags and taking action to protect loved ones.

Show Notes

Melissa Patton grows up in Locust Grove, Georgia with her parents and older sister, Tina. In high school, Melissa is head over heels for Christopher Wolfenbarger. The two quickly marry after graduating and move to Atlanta with their baby daughter Christina. When the couple welcomes a son, Joey, they settle in a duplex. Melissa works alongside her sister near the airport.

Thanksgiving Day, Melissa Wolfenbarger visits her parents, Carl and Norma Patton. Melissa is excited for the holidays and asks her mother for a very specific gift. When Melissa doesn’t even call Christmas day, Norma Patton is unsettled. Melissa doesn’t have a cell phone or a car, so Norma assumes her daughter is busy with her own family and will pick up her gifts later. When Melissa doesn’t wish her mom a happy birthday two months later, Norma Patton asks family members if anyone has seen her. Tina Patton realizes Melissa hasn’t worked a shift with her in months.  Then, Melissa misses her mother's birthday. 

Atlanta PD finds a severed human skull, that rolled out of a ripped trash bag in the middle of Avon Avenue.  Just over a month later, four more trash bags are discovered two blocks down Avon in wooded area. Inside are a pair of legs and arms. Police cannot locate a torso. It would be more than four years before the body is identified as Melissa Wolfenbarger, and 25 years before police arrest her killer. 

Joining Nancy Grace today: 

  • Tina Patton  - Sister of Melissa Wolfenbarger
  • Norma Patton  - Mother of Melissa Wolfenbarger
  • Darryl Cohen  -  Former Assistant District Attorney,  Former Assistant State Attorney, Defense Attorney, Cohen, Cooper, Estep, & Allen, LLC, CCEAlaw.com, Facebook: "Darryl B Cohen", Twitter: @DarrylBCohen
  • Sheryl McCullum - Cold Case Investigative Research Institute Founder, ColdCaseCrimes.org, Host of new podcast: Zone 7, Twitter: @ColdCaseTips
  • Joseph Scott Morgan - Professor of Forensics: Jacksonville State University, Author, "Blood Beneath My Feet", Host: "Body Bags with Joseph Scott Morgan", @JoScottForensic
  • Sydney Sumner - CrimeOnline investigative reporter

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Comments 
In Channel
loading

Table of contents

00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

GORGEOUS MOM DISAPPEARS AFTER FAMILY DINNER: WHAT HAPPENED TO MELISSA?

GORGEOUS MOM DISAPPEARS AFTER FAMILY DINNER: WHAT HAPPENED TO MELISSA?

iHeartPodcasts and CrimeOnline