How to Give Your Team the Feedback They Actually Need
3Digest
This podcast critiques traditional performance review systems, arguing that focusing on weaknesses is counterproductive. The hosts, Buckingham and Goodall, introduce the "feedback fallacy," explaining why constant criticism hinders growth. They redefine strengths as activities that energize and weaknesses as those that drain energy, regardless of skill level. The discussion emphasizes the importance of understanding individual growth patterns and utilizing a strengths-based approach to performance management. They challenge the reliability of performance data, including 360-degree reviews, highlighting inherent biases. The podcast proposes replacing traditional systems with methods focusing on individual experiences and self-assessment, suggesting practical steps for managers, such as using a "loved it/loathed it" exercise and regular short check-ins. The overall message promotes a shift towards a more supportive and effective performance management approach that fosters employee engagement and productivity.
Outlines
Rethinking Performance Management: A Strengths-Based Approach
This section introduces the concept of focusing on employee strengths rather than weaknesses for improved performance. It challenges traditional performance review systems and highlights how constructive criticism can hinder potential. The "feedback fallacy" is introduced, explaining the ineffectiveness of current feedback methods.
Addressing Performance and Organizational Change
This section discusses the importance of paying attention to employee performance without fixating on weaknesses. It emphasizes ongoing attention and the need for organizational structure changes to support a strengths-based approach. The unreliability of performance data and the need for reliable self-assessment are also discussed.
Practical Implementation and Next Steps
This section provides practical advice for managers on improving team engagement and productivity, including using a "loved it/loathed it" exercise and having regular short conversations with team members. It summarizes the key takeaways and encourages a shift towards a more effective performance management approach.
Keywords
Strengths-Based Development
A leadership approach focusing on identifying and developing employees' talents and strengths rather than solely addressing weaknesses. Improves engagement and performance.
Feedback Fallacy
The misconception that constant feedback, particularly on weaknesses, leads to improved performance. Research suggests this approach can be counterproductive.
Performance Management
The process of setting goals, monitoring progress, providing feedback, and evaluating employee performance. The episode advocates for a strengths-based approach.
Idiosyncratic Rater Effect
The tendency for raters to consistently rate individuals based on their own biases rather than objective performance. This impacts the reliability of performance reviews.
Adaptive Connections
Neural pathways in the brain that are strengthened through repeated use. The episode suggests focusing on areas where these connections are already strong for optimal growth.
Employee Engagement
The level of commitment and involvement employees have in their work and organization. A strengths-based approach can significantly improve employee engagement.
Productivity Improvement
Increasing the efficiency and effectiveness of employees and teams. Focusing on strengths contributes to higher productivity.
360-Degree Feedback
A performance appraisal method that gathers feedback from multiple sources, including supervisors, peers, and subordinates. The podcast questions its reliability.
Q&A
How can managers effectively address poor performance without hindering employee growth?
Focus on identifying specific missed steps or overlooked facts rather than broadly criticizing weaknesses. Help employees understand the root cause of the issue and find solutions within their existing skillset.
How can organizations move away from traditional feedback systems and create a more effective performance management approach?
Start by gathering direct feedback from employees to assess the effectiveness of current systems. Then, shift focus to measuring individual experiences and judgments rather than relying on unreliable rating systems. Implement systems that track what works well for each individual.
What are the key differences between the authors' definition of strengths and weaknesses and the common understanding?
They define strengths as activities that energize and invigorate, while weaknesses are activities that drain energy, regardless of skill level. This contrasts with the common understanding of strengths as areas of high skill and weaknesses as areas of low skill.
What practical steps can managers take immediately to improve their team's engagement and productivity?
Implement a "loved it/loathed it" exercise to identify energizing and draining activities. Have short, regular check-in meetings to discuss near-term work. View "good job" as the start of a conversation, not the end.
Show Notes
How does critical feedback affect your team’s success? Researchers Marcus Buckingham and Ashley Goodall argue that many managers invest too much energy in correcting weaknesses. Instead, they encourage leaders to focus on developing employees’ strengths. Buckingham and Goodall are the authors of the book, Nine Lies About Work: A Freethinking Leader’s Guide to the Real World and the HBR article “The Feedback Fallacy” In this episode, they explain how to lead more effective conversations about performance by focusing on what your team members do best.
Key episode topics include leadership, giving feedback, managing people, performance indicators.
HBR On Leadership curates the best case studies and conversations with the world’s top business and management experts, to help you unlock the best in those around you. New episodes every week.
- Listen to the original HBR IdeaCast episode: What Managers Get Wrong About Feedback (2019)
- Find more episodes of HBR IdeaCast.
- Discover 100 years of Harvard Business Review articles, case studies, podcasts, and more at HBR.org.
Table of contents
United States
