DiscoverBad On PaperIsola Book Club
Isola Book Club

Isola Book Club

Update: 2025-02-261
Share

Digest

This podcast episode reviews Allegra Goodman's *Izola*, a historical fiction novel based on the true story of Marguerite de Roberval. The hosts share their personal updates, including both positive and negative experiences. They then delve into a detailed discussion of *Izola*, offering contrasting perspectives. One host loved the immersive world-building and compelling narrative, while the other found it slow and lacking in historical detail. The surprising selection of *Izola* as a Reese's Book Club pick is debated, along with its potential for adaptation. A fun segment involves rating their survival skills based on scenarios presented in the book. The episode concludes with a discussion of the real-life inspiration behind *Izola*, alternative survival stories, book recommendations (including *Project Hail Mary* and *Hatchet*), and the announcement of the next book club selection: *Deep Cuts* by Holly Brickley.

Outlines

00:00:00
February Highlights & *Izola* Introduction

The podcast begins with personal updates from the hosts, covering both positive and negative experiences from February, before introducing the book club's focus on *Izola* by Allegra Goodman.

00:05:03
*Izola* Review & Contrasting Opinions

The hosts provide a brief summary of *Izola* and share their contrasting opinions. One host praises the immersive world, while the other criticizes the pacing and historical accuracy.

00:22:10
Reese's Book Club, Adaptation Potential & Survival Scenarios

The hosts discuss *Izola*'s selection for Reese's Book Club, its potential for adaptation, and rate their ability to survive various scenarios depicted in the book (island survival, hunting, etc.).

00:44:08
*Izola*'s Inspiration, Deaths & Alternative Recommendations

The episode explores the true story behind *Izola*, discusses the numerous deaths within the narrative, and offers alternative book recommendations for listeners who didn't enjoy *Izola*.

00:49:39
Current Obsessions & March Book Club Pick

The hosts share their current obsessions and announce March's book club selection: *Deep Cuts* by Holly Brickley.

Keywords

Izola (book)


A historical fiction novel by Allegra Goodman based on the true story of Marguerite de Roberval, exploring themes of survival and resilience.

Reese's Book Club


A popular book club curated by Reese Witherspoon, known for selecting commercially successful and adaptable novels.

Historical Fiction


A genre of fiction incorporating historical settings, events, and characters.

Survival Story


A narrative focusing on a character's struggle to survive challenging circumstances.

Immersive World-Building


A narrative technique creating a detailed and believable fictional world.

Book Review


A critical assessment of a book, including plot summary, character analysis, and overall evaluation.

Allegra Goodman


Author of the historical fiction novel *Izola*.

Marguerite de Roberval


The historical figure who inspired the novel *Izola*.

Q&A

  • What were the hosts' contrasting opinions on *Izola*, and what aspects of the book contributed to these differing perspectives?

    One host appreciated the immersive world-building, while the other found the pacing slow and the historical details lacking.

  • Why was *Izola*'s selection as a Reese's Book Club pick surprising, and what are the implications for the book's potential adaptation?

    *Izola*'s slower pace contrasts with Reese's Book Club's typical selections, raising questions about its suitability for adaptation.

  • What were some of the key survival scenarios discussed, and how did the hosts rate their own abilities to cope with these challenges?

    Scenarios included island selection, hunting, and dealing with harsh weather. The hosts' ratings varied widely.

  • What is the true story behind *Izola*, and how did the author incorporate this historical inspiration into the novel?

    *Izola* is based on the true story of Marguerite de Roberval, with the author weaving together different versions of her tale.

  • What other books did the hosts recommend, and why?

    *Project Hail Mary* and *Hatchet* were recommended as alternative survival stories.

Show Notes

February has flown, and it's time for book club! We're excited to discuss Isola by Allegra Goodman, a polarizing pick within the pod. We're covering our expectations before reading, the pacing, how we'd handle the scenarios the characters found themselves in, and more!

 

Obsessions

Becca  - Leopard Adidas x Wales Bonner sneakers

 

What we read this week

Olivia - Saint X by Alexis Schaitkin, Good Dirt by Charmaine Wilkerson

Becca - This Love by Lotte Jeffs

 

This Month's Book Club Pick - Deep Cuts by Holly Brickley (have thoughts about this book you want to share? Call in at 843-405-3157 or email us a voice memo at badonpaperpodcast@gmail.com)

 

Sponsors

Cozy Earth - Get 40% off your purchase at cozyearth.com/BOP or use our code BOP.

Prose - Get your free consultation and 50% off your custom routine at Prose.com/bop.

 

Join our Facebook group for amazing book recs & more! 

Buy our Merch!

Join our Geneva!

Order Olivia's Book, Such a Bad Influence!

Subscribe to Olivia's Newsletter!

Order Becca's Book, The Christmas Orphans Club!

Subscribe to Becca's Newsletter! 

Follow us on Instagram @badonpaperpodcast. Follow Olivia on Instagram @oliviamuenter and Becca @beccamfreeman.

 

Comments 
In Channel
May 2026 Three Things

May 2026 Three Things

2026-05-1301:16:43

Spring 2026 Catch Up

Spring 2026 Catch Up

2026-05-0601:01:47

Good People Book Club

Good People Book Club

2026-04-2901:01:12

Hidden Gem Reads Redux

Hidden Gem Reads Redux

2026-04-2252:45

April 2026 Three Things

April 2026 Three Things

2026-04-1501:22:37

2026 Publishing Trends

2026 Publishing Trends

2026-04-0801:13:03

The 8th Anniversary Episode

The 8th Anniversary Episode

2026-04-0101:47:17

So Old, So Young Book Club

So Old, So Young Book Club

2026-03-2501:18:26

March 2026 Three Things

March 2026 Three Things

2026-03-1101:14:24

Little One Book Club

Little One Book Club

2026-02-2501:27:07

February 2026 Three Things

February 2026 Three Things

2026-02-1801:24:19

Obscure Erotica 2026

Obscure Erotica 2026

2026-02-1152:20

The Heated Rivalry Episode

The Heated Rivalry Episode

2026-02-0401:44:48

2026 Reading Preview

2026 Reading Preview

2026-01-2101:19:41

January 2026 Three Things

January 2026 Three Things

2026-01-1401:17:49

2026 Goals

2026 Goals

2026-01-0701:32:33

loading

Table of contents

00:00
00:00
1.0x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

Isola Book Club

Isola Book Club

Becca Freeman & Olivia Muenter