Digest

This episode of "My Favorite Murder" presents a mini-sode filled with listener-submitted stories, primarily centered around the themes of Easter and Passover. The tales include a neighbor's haunted house where dogs reacted to an unseen presence, later seemingly confirmed by a toddler's pronouncements. Another story involves a Passover Seder where a guest revealed a connection to a true-crime podcast through the shocking tale of a rabbi who hired a hitman. Other anecdotes feature a remarkable childhood coincidence discovered through old photos, a dangerous incident involving eating Easter egg dye pellets, a chaotic family Easter egg hunt in Wales, and a dramatic escape and pursuit of a pet cockatiel.

Outlines

00:02:00

Spooky Encounters and Holiday Tales

This chapter covers listener stories about a haunted house with barking dogs and a toddler's eerie pronouncements, a Passover Seder featuring a hitman rabbi story and a podcast connection, and a childhood coincidence discovered through old photos.

00:15:23

Childhood Mishaps and Holiday Chaos

This chapter includes a listener's dangerous childhood mistake of eating Easter egg dye pellets, the chaotic adventure of a runaway cockatiel named Billy on Easter, and an unhinged Easter egg hunt orchestrated by drunken uncles in Wales.

Keywords

Q&A

• What was the unusual behavior of the dogs in the listener's neighbor's haunted house story?

  The dogs would congregate in the same spot every night and bark relentlessly into the air, as if looking at or reacting to something unseen.

• How did a toddler seemingly confirm the presence of a ghost in the haunted house?

  Years later, at a Passover Seder, the toddler pointed to the spot where the dogs used to bark and said "ghost," and later pointed to the floor saying "dead body," shocking the adults.

• What surprising connection was made during the pot-fueled Passover Seder story?

  A listener realized they had heard the story of Fred Newlander, a rabbi who hired a hitman, on the "My Favorite Murder" podcast, and a fellow guest recognized the podcast as well.

• What was the remarkable coincidence in the Easter egg hunt photo story?

  The listener and their partner discovered they were both present at the same Easter egg hunt as young children, captured in the same photograph, years before they met.

• What dangerous mistake did the listener make as a child related to Easter egg dyeing?

  The listener ate an entire box of Easter egg dye pellets, mistaking them for candy, which led to a call to poison control but thankfully no serious toxicity.

• What was the "Great Easter Escape" involving the family cockatiel?

  The family's pet cockatiel, Billy, escaped on Easter Sunday and led the father on a chaotic chase across town through woods and backyards before finally being coaxed down from a tree.

• How did the family's Easter egg hunt become unhinged?

  The hunt was planned by drunken uncles, resulting in nonsensical clues, eggs hidden in dangerous or inaccessible places, and a general lack of order, which was eventually salvaged by the women of the family.

Show Notes