Mormonism Failed Me as A Woman - Dana Raine | Ep. 1999
Digest
This podcast features Dana Reyn, a former guest, sharing her honest and vulnerable experience as a young Mormon woman. Raised in a predominantly non-Mormon community, her family's conversion and subsequent move to Utah brought both positive and negative experiences. She describes initial disappointments in fitting in, challenges with the Church's portrayal of women, and the pressure to conform to traditional gender roles. Her teenage years were marked by dedication to the Church, but also by a severe OCD diagnosis, self-harm, and internal conflict. College in Boston led to a mental health crisis and a reevaluation of her future within the Church. Preparing for her temple endowment and mission amplified her anxieties, and the mission itself proved challenging and rigid. The discovery of the CES Letter significantly impacted her faith, leading to a rapid deconstruction of her beliefs. Further complicating matters was a PMDD diagnosis, which helped explain years of intense mental health struggles. After leaving the Church, Dana explored single motherhood by choice, experienced marriage and divorce, and ultimately underwent a hysterectomy to alleviate her PMDD symptoms. She now focuses on self-discovery, pursuing a PhD, and fostering children, having deconstructed her understanding of Mormon womanhood and prioritized her own well-being. She reflects on her journey, emphasizing self-advocacy and the importance of prioritizing mental and physical health.
Outlines

Introduction and Early Mormon Life
The podcast introduces Dana Reyn and her intention to honestly discuss her experiences leaving the Mormon Church after a devout upbringing, including her family's conversion story and positive early experiences within the Church.

Utah Experiences and Disillusionment
Dana details her family's move to Utah, the subsequent challenges of fitting in, disappointments with the local culture, and the limited opportunities for women within her community. This includes her struggles with other young women in her ward and the Church's portrayal of women's roles.

Mormon Culture, Family Dynamics, and Mental Health Challenges
This section covers the prevalent scrapbooking culture among Mormon women, Dana's teenage years, her relationship with her brother who struggled with the Church, her OCD diagnosis, and the impact of these factors on her mental health and faith.

High School, College, and the Abandonment of the Mormon Dream
Dana recounts her high school experience, including an incident involving self-harm, her college plans, her move to Boston, and the subsequent mental health crisis that led her to reconsider her future within the Church.

Temple Preparation, Mission Fears, and Mission Experience
Dana describes her anxieties and feelings of inadequacy while preparing for her temple endowment and her intense fear and reluctance to begin her mission, highlighting the internal conflict between societal expectations and personal anxieties. Her mission experience is described as rigid and numbers-driven, exacerbating her pre-existing anxiety and mental health issues.

BYU, Loss of Faith, and Leaving Mormonism
Dana discusses her transition to BYU, the challenges of dating within the Mormon community, her discovery of the CES Letter and the profound impact it had on her faith, and the factors that influenced her decision to leave the Church.

PMDD Diagnosis, Single Motherhood, and Marriage
Dana recounts her PMDD diagnosis and how understanding this condition helped explain years of intense mental health struggles. She details her experiences with artificial insemination, marriage, and the unexpected turn of events that led to a relationship and marriage.

Divorce, Hysterectomy, and a New Chapter
Dana shares the complexities of her marriage, the challenges of navigating unhealthy relationship dynamics, her ultimate decision to divorce, her decision to undergo a hysterectomy, her experience as a foster parent, and her current pursuit of a PhD.

Deconstructing Mormon Womanhood and Future Hopes
Dana reflects on the deconstruction of her understanding of Mormon womanhood, highlighting the shift from prioritizing others' expectations to prioritizing her own well-being and self-actualization. She discusses her future hopes, including the possibility of adoption and building a chosen family.
Keywords
Young Mormon Women
Experiences, challenges, and perspectives of women raised in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Mormon Identity Crisis
Struggle faced by individuals raised in the LDS faith who question their beliefs and identity.
Religious Trauma Syndrome
Symptoms resulting from harmful religious experiences, including abuse and control.
OCD (Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder)
Mental health condition characterized by intrusive thoughts and repetitive behaviors.
Faith Crisis
Period of questioning or loss of faith, leading to a reevaluation of religious beliefs.
Temple Endowment
Sacred ceremony in the LDS Church symbolizing covenants with God.
Mormon Mission
Full-time missionary service for young adult members of the LDS Church.
CES Letter
Essay detailing alleged historical and doctrinal inconsistencies within the LDS Church.
PMDD (Premenstrual Dysphoric Disorder)
Severe form of PMS characterized by debilitating mood swings, depression, and anxiety.
Single Motherhood by Choice
Conscious decision of a woman to become a mother without a partner.
Q&A
What were the biggest challenges Dana faced as a young Mormon woman trying to live up to the Church's expectations?
Balancing devout membership with her evolving identity and mental health struggles, pressure to conform to traditional gender roles, and intense scrutiny of worthiness interviews.
How did Dana's family dynamics influence her relationship with the Church?
Her older brother's struggles with the Church significantly impacted her, leading to a highly conscientious adherence to Church standards.
What led to Dana's decision to leave the traditional Mormon path?
Mental health challenges, pressure to conform, a feeling of not fitting in, and a growing realization that the traditional Mormon path wasn't fulfilling.
What was Dana's experience on her mission?
The mission exacerbated her pre-existing anxiety and mental health issues due to its rigid structure and limited contact with family.
How did the discovery of the CES Letter impact her faith?
The CES Letter's presentation of historical inconsistencies led to a rapid loss of faith.
What were Dana's experiences with dating within the Mormon community?
Significant pressure to marry young and the emotional toll of failed relationships within a limited pool of potential partners.
How did Dana's mental health affect her experiences within the Mormon Church?
Her pre-existing mental health conditions were significantly exacerbated by the intense pressure and rigid structure of the Mormon community.
What ultimately led to Dana's departure from the Mormon Church?
Personal struggles with mental health, challenges navigating Mormon expectations, and the revelation of historical inconsistencies in the CES Letter.
How did your experience with PMDD intersect with your journey out of the Mormon Church?
The PMDD diagnosis helped separate her mental health from her religious beliefs, allowing her to focus on self-care and healing.
How has your understanding of Mormon womanhood evolved since leaving the Church?
From fulfilling prescribed roles to a focus on self-discovery and self-actualization, prioritizing her own well-being.
Show Notes
Dana shares her personal journey of growing up in the Mormon church, navigating mental health challenges, and eventually deconstructing her faith. From her Mormon upbringing and mission experience to questioning societal and religious expectations, Dana's story explores themes of self-discovery, the impact of religion on her life, and the search for meaning beyond traditional beliefs. After leaving the church, Dana delves into topics like mental health, fertility, relationships, and motherhood, offering a candid perspective on her path toward healing and personal growth. This channel is a space for open discussion on faith, identity, and life after Mormonism.
00:05:00 Dana’s Mormon Story begins
00:17:00 What examples did she see of women in the church?
00:21:34 It was out of the ordinary to see women with careers
00:38:23 She was reported to the Bishop and her parents that she had experimented with cutting
01:06:30 Dana’s mission experience service in Atlanta, Georgia
01:12:22 She didn't love the temple experience - was “underwhelming”
01:24:24 David Archuleta was at the MTC during the same time
01:32:51 Dana knew very soon that she wanted to leave the mission early and she had to fight to go home
01:38:27 Dana Decided to go to BYU
01:56:25 Felt pressure to be married by the time she finished BYU
02:02:17 Dana to tell her parents that they could not be married in the temple and her mother told her “He’s taken everything from you”
02:18:07 Mormon therapist asked her to consider if she would be open to dating a non-Mormon
02:29:50 Dana lists the ways the church failed her - the church makes promises it can’t keep
02:41:20 Began to research severe PMS and PMDD, and learned that she suffered from it
02:47:02 Dana decided to have a baby by herself - very radical in Mormonism
03:08:00 Dana feels that she was a better foster parent as an ex-Mormon
03:14:40 Deconstructing the idea of “motherhood” in Mormonism
03:27:18 Dana focusing on her PhD
Mormon Stories Thanks Our Generous Donors!
Help us continue to deliver quality content by becoming a donor today:
Our Platforms:
Contact us:
MormonStories@gmail.com
PO Box 171085, Salt Lake City, UT 84117
Social Media:




