DiscoverThe Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFLOffseason Buy or Sell: The Playoff Hopefuls
Offseason Buy or Sell: The Playoff Hopefuls

Offseason Buy or Sell: The Playoff Hopefuls

Update: 2025-05-20
Share

Digest

This podcast dissects the off-season moves of multiple NFL playoff hopeful teams, offering a "buy" or "sell" assessment for each. The analysis considers coaching changes, player acquisitions (via free agency and trades), draft picks, player age, contract structures, and team cohesion. The Denver Broncos receive high praise for their strategic acquisitions of impactful defensive and offensive players. Conversely, the Houston Texans' off-season is heavily criticized for their mismanagement of the offensive line, particularly the trade of their best lineman. Other teams, including the Vikings, Bengals, Buccaneers, Packers, and Chargers, receive mixed reviews, with concerns often revolving around the secondary, offensive and defensive line strength, player age, and contract structures. The podcast highlights the challenges of rebuilding an offensive line and the varying approaches teams take to free agency depending on their stage of development (rebuilding vs. contending). The discussion also touches upon the complexities of player agency and team building, using the example of Caleb Williams' draft selection and subsequent comments.

Outlines

00:02:05
NFL Offseason: Playoff Hopeful Team Analyses

An overview of the offseason moves of several NFL playoff hopeful teams, including the Vikings, Bengals, Buccaneers, Packers, Broncos, Texans, and Chargers. Each team's moves are analyzed, considering coaching changes, player acquisitions, draft picks, and overall team strategy, resulting in a "buy" or "sell" recommendation for each team's offseason performance.

00:23:05
Minnesota Vikings Offseason Deep Dive

Detailed analysis of the Vikings' offseason, focusing on their offensive and defensive line upgrades and the implications for their rookie quarterback. A "buy" rating is given, but concerns about the secondary and older players are noted.

00:33:49
Cincinnati Bengals and Tampa Bay Buccaneers Offseason Reviews

Evaluates the Bengals' and Buccaneers' offseasons. The Bengals' defensive investments and coaching changes are highlighted, but concerns about overall improvement and contract structures lead to a "sell" rating. The Buccaneers' draft picks and free agent signings are analyzed, with concerns about their lack of urgency in addressing defensive needs resulting in a "sell" rating.

00:50:42
Green Bay Packers and Denver Broncos Offseason Assessments

Examines the Packers' and Broncos' offseasons. The Packers' offensive line improvements and draft picks are discussed, leading to a cautious "buy" rating due to concerns about the secondary and team cohesion. The Broncos' additions of impactful defensive and offensive players earn them a strong "buy" rating, despite acknowledging some injury risk.

01:06:52
Houston Texans Offseason Critique: Offensive Line Failures

A critical analysis of the Texans' offseason, focusing on their disastrous handling of the offensive line, including the trade of their best lineman and unimpressive replacements.

01:15:38
Los Angeles Chargers Offseason Evaluation: A Cautious Approach

Discussion of the Chargers' offseason, ultimately leaning towards a "sell" rating due to a lack of aggressive improvement, especially on defense. The team's young core and measured approach to free agency are discussed.

00:00:00
Introduction: Setting the Stage for Offseason Analysis

A brief introduction to the podcast, outlining the teams to be discussed and the criteria used for evaluating their offseason performance.

00:00:00
Conclusion: Key Takeaways and Future Outlook

Summarizes the key findings from the podcast, highlighting the successes and failures of different teams' offseason strategies and offering a brief outlook on the upcoming season.

Keywords

NFL Offseason


The period after the NFL season concludes and before the next season begins, characterized by free agency, trades, and the NFL Draft.

Playoff Hopefuls


NFL teams projected to contend for a playoff berth.

Offensive Line


The group of five players responsible for blocking defensive players.

Defensive Line


The group of players responsible for pressuring the quarterback and stopping the run.

NFL Free Agency Strategy


Methods NFL teams use to acquire players during free agency.

Contract Structure


Terms and conditions of a player's contract.

Draft Capital Management


How NFL teams utilize their draft picks.

Aggressiveness in NFL Offseason Moves


Degree to which a team makes significant roster changes.

Offensive Line Rebuilding


Process of improving an NFL team's offensive line.

Q&A

  • What were the main factors considered when evaluating each team's off-season?

    Coaching changes, player acquisitions, draft picks, player age, contract structures, and team cohesion.

  • Which team's off-season was most highly praised, and why?

    The Denver Broncos, due to strategic acquisitions of impactful players.

  • What were some recurring concerns expressed throughout the podcast?

    Strong offensive and defensive lines, player age and injury history, contract structures, and team cohesion.

  • What was the main criticism of the Houston Texans' offseason moves?

    Their mismanagement of the offensive line, particularly trading their best lineman.

  • Why did the hosts ultimately "sell" the Los Angeles Chargers' offseason?

    Their lack of aggressive improvement, especially on defense.

  • What are the challenges associated with rebuilding an offensive line in the NFL?

    Finding and developing high-quality offensive linemen is difficult.

  • How do different NFL teams approach the offseason based on their stage of development?

    Contending teams are more aggressive, while rebuilding teams prioritize drafting and development.

Show Notes

Seven of the eight teams in this edition of Offseason Buy or Sell made the playoffs last year, and the one that didn't, the Bengals, had one of the best offenses in the league. In other words, each of these teams goes into this season with realistic playoff hopes, and some of them are harboring even bigger dreams than that. So how do we feel about what they all did this offseason? Robert Mays and Derrik Klassen make buy or sell calls on the Steelers, Vikings, Bengals, Buccaneers, Packers, Broncos, Texans and Chargers on this episode of The Athletic Football Show.


Hosts: Robert Mays and Derrik Klassen

Executive Producer: Michael Beller

Producer: Michael Beller

Subscribe to The Athletic Football Show...

⁠Apple⁠

⁠Spotify⁠

⁠YouTube⁠

Follow Robert on Bluesky: @robertmays.bsky.social

Follow Derrik on Bluesky: @qbklass.bsky.social

Follow Robert on X: @robertmays

Follow Derrik on X: @QBKlass

Theme song: Haunted

Written by Dylan Slocum, Trevor Dietrich, Ruben Duarte, Kyle McAulay, and Meredith VanWoert / Performed by Spanish Love Songs

Courtesy of Pure Noise / By arrangement with Bank Robber Music, LLC


Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Comments 
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

Offseason Buy or Sell: The Playoff Hopefuls

Offseason Buy or Sell: The Playoff Hopefuls