DiscoverThe Dr. Phil PodcastPart 2: The Husband Accused of Poisoning His Wife: His Arrest and the Aftermath
Part 2: The Husband Accused of Poisoning His Wife: His Arrest and the Aftermath

Part 2: The Husband Accused of Poisoning His Wife: His Arrest and the Aftermath

Update: 2026-04-14
Share

Digest

This podcast chronicles Catherine Herring's harrowing experience of surviving her husband's seven attempts to harm her and their unborn child. After discovering his plot, which included attempts to induce abortion and physical harm, Catherine gathered evidence with the help of a private investigator. The confirmation of his actions through video and lab results led her to pursue justice, emphasizing the critical role of her support system in navigating the psychological and emotional complexities of domestic violence. The narrative details the slow legal process, the fear of retaliation, her daughter Josephine's premature birth and subsequent health challenges, and the eventual sentencing of her husband for felony assault. The conversation also explores the long-term neurological effects of trauma and Catherine's current self-care practices, including therapy and her establishment of the Stay At Your Home Mom Foundation, which provides financial assistance to domestic violence survivors.

Outlines

00:00:00
Husband's Betrayal and Escalating Attacks

The podcast begins with Catherine Herring's story, detailing her husband's attempts to harm her and their unborn child after she announced her third pregnancy. This includes escalating attempts on her life, the involvement of a private investigator, and the discovery of crucial evidence like hidden cameras and abortion pill packets. Confronting the truth through video evidence and lab results solidified her resolve to seek justice.

00:05:56
The Insidious Nature of Abuse and Support Systems

Catherine emphasizes the importance of her support team in navigating the dangerous situation and maintaining safety, highlighting the cognitive dissonance inherent in domestic violence. The discussion delves into the multifaceted and insidious nature of domestic violence, noting that psychological and emotional abuse can be harder to combat than physical aggression. Witnessing the video evidence became a catalyst for her resolve, compounded by the grief and fear of caring for her existing children.

00:09:41
Legal Battles, Arrest, and Protective Measures

Despite her husband's arrest, Catherine lived in fear of retaliation, detailing the slow legal process and the challenges of dealing with an abuser's quick release. The podcast outlines the process of reporting her husband to the police, evidence gathering, and the subsequent arrest, highlighting the slow pace of the justice system. The establishment of a protective order is discussed, along with the tense period between the police report and the arrest, during which Catherine actively avoided her husband.

00:14:56
Daughter's Birth, Health Journey, and Legal Setbacks

Catherine shares the emotional experience of her daughter's premature birth and the subsequent legal battles, including the initial charges against her husband and their eventual reduction. The podcast details the health challenges faced by her daughter, Josephine, including numerous hospitalizations and surgeries, and her remarkable progress through therapy.

00:19:12
Unseen Consequences and Legal Accountability

Catherine reflects on the unnecessary suffering endured by her and her daughter, the absence of her husband from Josephine's life, and the ongoing legal complexities. The podcast discusses the legal consequences for Catherine's husband, including his sentencing for felony assault and injury to a child, and the subsequent violation of his plea agreement.

00:34:21
Trauma's Lasting Effects and Path to Healing

The conversation shifts to the profound and lasting psychological and neurological impact of trauma on Catherine, emphasizing how such experiences can alter brain structure. Catherine shares her current self-care practices, including therapy, nature, and a renewed sense of faith, which help her manage complex PTSD and its effects.

00:42:29
The Stay At Your Home Mom Foundation

Catherine introduces her foundation, which aims to provide financial assistance, specifically zero-interest mortgage loans, to domestic violence survivors to help them maintain housing stability.

Keywords

Domestic Violence


A pattern of abusive behaviors used by one partner to maintain power and control over another in a relationship, including physical, emotional, sexual, or financial abuse.

Attempted Abortion


The act of trying to terminate a pregnancy through harmful means, often involving substances or actions intended to cause miscarriage, as a deliberate act by the husband in this case.

Protective Order


A court order designed to protect an individual from a threatening or harassing person, typically prohibiting contact and establishing safe distances.

Felony Assault on a Pregnant Person


A serious criminal charge involving an unlawful attack or threat of attack against a pregnant individual with the intent to cause harm or endanger the pregnancy.

Injury to a Child


A legal term referring to causing harm or endangerment to a child, often resulting from abuse or neglect.

Complex PTSD (C-PTSD)


A trauma-related disorder developing after prolonged exposure to overwhelming stress, such as domestic abuse, affecting emotional regulation, self-perception, and relationships.

Financial Abuse


A form of domestic violence where one partner controls the other's access to money and economic resources as a tool for power and control.

Cognitive Dissonance


Mental discomfort from holding contradictory beliefs or encountering conflicting information, often leading to confusion and denial in domestic violence situations.

Trauma's Neurological Impact


The lasting psychological and neurological effects of trauma, which can alter brain structure and affect areas responsible for arousal and stress responses.

Stay At Your Home Mom Foundation


A foundation providing financial assistance, such as zero-interest mortgage loans, to domestic violence survivors to help them maintain housing stability.

Q&A

  • How many times did Catherine's husband attempt to harm her and the baby?

    Catherine's husband attempted to harm her and their unborn child a total of seven times. She consumed the first drink, and the remaining six were collected as evidence.

  • What was the initial charge against Catherine's husband?

    Initially, Catherine's husband was charged with felony assault to induce abortion. However, this charge changed after their daughter, Josephine, was born.

  • What is the Stay At Your Home Mom Foundation, and what does it aim to achieve?

    The Stay At Your Home Mom Foundation, launched by Catherine, aims to provide domestic violence survivors with zero-interest home mortgage loans and other assistance to help them maintain housing stability during and after abusive situations.

  • How did Catherine's husband's legal situation evolve after the initial sentencing?

    After violating the terms of his plea agreement and protective order, Catherine's husband faced new charges and was ultimately sentenced to eight years for the original offenses of felony assault of a pregnant person and felony assault for injury of a child.

  • What are the long-term effects of such trauma on the brain?

    Prolonged stress and trauma can neurologically alter the brain's structure, affecting areas like the cingulate gyrus and amygdala, which are responsible for arousal systems and the fight-or-flight response.

Show Notes

Part 2: Dr. Phil’s exclusive interview with Catherine Herring, a wife who made national headlines after her husband was arrested and accused of secretly poisoning her drinks, on multiple occasions with an abortion inducing medication in a sole attempt to terminate her pregnancy. Tonight, Dr. Phil sits down with Catherine to discuss the aftermath of his arrest and guilty plea she claims was no justice at all. Plus, find out if Catherine’s now ex-husband has a relationship with the child Catherine was carrying during the alleged poisoning attempts.

Thank you to our sponsors who helped make this episode possible:

Don’t wait! If you’re on Medicare or will be soon, reach out to Chapter: Call: (352)-845-0659 or go to https://askchapter.org/ to learn about your Medicare options and get help finding ways to save money.


The You Can Do It Foundation supports meaningful media that reflects faith, family, personal responsibility, and freedom. Partnering with industry leaders, we create content that resonates and inspires. Learn more, donate and support the mission: https://ycdif.com/


Preserve Gold - text "ASK PHIL" to 50505 and go to https://DrPhilGold.com


See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Comments 
In Channel

Table of contents

00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

Part 2: The Husband Accused of Poisoning His Wife: His Arrest and the Aftermath

Part 2: The Husband Accused of Poisoning His Wife: His Arrest and the Aftermath