Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 89: The Finch
Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 89: The Finch
3Digest
This episode of "Rewind with Karen and Georgia" revisits episode 89, "The Finch," offering new commentary on past discussions. The hosts touch on their podcasting philosophy, the relevance of math, and lighthearted musings before diving into true crime. They discuss the disturbing case of Dean Corll, "The Candyman," a serial killer who preyed on young boys in Houston, detailing his methods, accomplices David Brooks and Wayne Henley, and the systemic failures that allowed his crimes to continue. The conversation then shifts to the murder of Larry Austin at the Silent Movie Theater in Los Angeles, revealing the plot orchestrated by James Van Sickle and carried out by Christian Rodriguez, and the subsequent convictions. The episode concludes with updates on the cases, reflections on the psychological toll of true crime, and the hosts' "good things of the week."
Outlines
Podcast Introduction and Episode Recap
Karen and Georgia introduce their podcast "Rewind with Karen and Georgia," where they revisit old episodes with new commentary, focusing on episode 89, "The Finch." They discuss their approach to not providing direct answers, the practical application of math, and share lighthearted thoughts on movies and fashion.
True Crime Focus and Fan Creations
The hosts transition to the true crime aspect of their podcast, assuring listeners they are in the right place for murder stories. They express excitement over a fan-created video game based on their show and reminisce about childhood education experiences.
Live Shows, TV Anticipation, and Friendship Dynamics
Karen and Georgia express gratitude for their live shows and share a heartwarming fan sign. They discuss their anticipation for the Netflix series "Mindhunter" and reflect on their close friendship, noting how their therapists describe them as complementary. They also highlight the positive impact of their openness about mental health on listeners seeking therapy.
The Dean Corll "Candyman" Murders: Introduction and Background
The hosts introduce the horrific case of Dean Corll, "The Candyman," a serial killer responsible for the deaths of numerous young boys in Houston, Texas. They credit their research sources and begin detailing Corll's modus operandi, his "Candy Man" persona used to lure victims, and the early involvement of his teenage accomplices, David Brooks and Wayne Henley.
Escalating Violence and Accomplice Complicity
The narrative details the first acts of violence and the unexplained resilience of Corll. The hosts explore the increasing depravity of the crimes, including the murders of the Waldrop brothers, and the deep devotion and continued complicity of Brooks and Henley, highlighting Corll's manipulative control.
Scale of Tragedy and Systemic Failures
The sheer number of victims is revealed, emphasizing the widespread impact of Corll's crimes. The hosts criticize the police's dismissive attitude towards missing persons reports, attributing it to the era's norms and systemic failures, and suggest the case as a compelling subject for a David Fincher film.
Investigation Challenges and Accountability
The lack of modern communication technology in the 1970s is discussed as a factor in crime solving. Controversial police actions, including raids and the use of inmate labor for excavation, are mentioned. The authorities' decision to halt excavation is questioned, leading to a discussion on the importance of truth and accountability, especially in law enforcement.
Legal Consequences and Lingering Questions
Accomplices Henley and Brooks receive life sentences, and ongoing efforts to identify victims are noted. The discovery of a Polaroid photo raises speculation about an additional victim and past accomplices becoming victims themselves, underscoring the ripple effect of the tragedy.
Psychological Impact and Case Conclusion
The hosts reflect on the disturbing details of the Dean Corll case, discussing the emotional impact and the struggle to maintain empathy. They provide updates on David Brooks' death and Elmer Henley's parole denials, concluding the segment with a somber reflection on the enduring horror of the "Candyman" case.
The Silent Movie Theater Murders: Case Overview
The hosts introduce the case of the Silent Movie Theater murders in Los Angeles, detailing the theater's history, its reopening, and the tragic events of its sixth anniversary celebration where a robbery escalated into murder.
Investigation, Identification, and Convictions
The investigation identifies James Van Sickle as the mastermind and Christian Rodriguez as the hired hitman. Van Sickle's financial motive is revealed, leading to the convictions of Rodriguez for murder and attempted murder, and Van Sickle for murder, with Mary Giles surviving to testify.
Theater Updates and Personal Reflections
Updates on the Silent Movie Theater's closure due to financial and harassment allegations are provided, along with its current status as a venue for a streetwear company. The hosts share their "good things of the week," finding synchronicity in purchasing the same lamp, and recap favorite moments from the episode.
Keywords
Rewind with Karen and Georgia
A podcast series where hosts Karen and Georgia revisit and discuss past episodes of their show, "My Favorite Murder," offering new insights and commentary.
True Crime Podcast
A podcast genre dedicated to the discussion and analysis of real-life criminal cases, often involving murder, disappearances, and other serious offenses.
Dean Corll
The central figure in the discussed case, also known as "The Candyman," a serial killer responsible for the abduction, rape, and murder of numerous young boys in Houston, Texas, during the 1970s.
"The Candyman" Case
Refers to the series of murders committed by Dean Corll, named after his family's candy business and his practice of giving free candy to children, particularly teenage boys, whom he would then lure and abuse.
David Brooks
A teenage accomplice of Dean Corll who became involved in the murders, initially as a mentee and later as a participant, lured by Corll's manipulation and promises.
Wayne Henley
Another accomplice in the Dean Corll murders. Initially invited to Corll's house, he became involved in the crimes and later confessed, leading authorities to the victims' bodies.
Houston Mass Murders
A term used to describe the series of murders committed by Dean Corll and his accomplices in and around Houston, Texas, involving at least 28 young male victims.
Serial Killer Psychology
Explores the motivations, grooming tactics, and psychological manipulation employed by serial killers, examining how individuals can be influenced or controlled, and the societal factors that may contribute to such behavior.
Silent Movie Theater Murders
Details the 1997 murder of Larry Austin at the historic Silent Movie Theater in Los Angeles. The case involves a complex relationship, a staged robbery, and the subsequent investigation and convictions.
James Van Sickle
The contractor involved in the Silent Movie Theater's renovation and Larry Austin's lover. He is identified as the mastermind behind Austin's murder, driven by financial motives and a desire for inheritance.
Q&A
What is "Rewind with Karen and Georgia"?
"Rewind with Karen and Georgia" is a podcast series where hosts Karen and Georgia revisit and discuss past episodes of their show, "My Favorite Murder," offering new insights and commentary on previously covered cases.
Who was Dean Corll and what was his nickname?
Dean Corll, also known as "The Candyman," was a serial killer who abducted, raped, and murdered numerous young boys in Houston, Texas, during the 1970s. His nickname came from his family's candy business and his practice of giving free candy to children.
What role did David Brooks play in Dean Corll's crimes?
David Brooks was a teenage accomplice of Dean Corll. Initially mentored by Corll, Brooks became involved in the murders, luring victims and participating in the crimes, manipulated by Corll's promises and threats.
How did the police initially handle the missing persons reports related to Dean Corll's crimes?
The police were largely dismissive of the missing persons reports, often labeling the victims as runaways. This inaction was attributed to the era's norms, an understaffed and underfunded police force, and a focus on wealthier residents.
What is the significance of the "handcuff game" in the context of Dean Corll's crimes?
The "handcuff game" was a method used by Corll and his accomplices to trap victims. They would trick individuals into putting on handcuffs, then reveal that the key was hidden, leaving the victim vulnerable to assault and murder.
How many victims were officially attributed to Dean Corll and his accomplices?
Officially, 28 young males, ranging in age from nine to 21, were victims of Dean Corll and his accomplices. However, the hosts speculate that there may have been more unidentified victims.
What is the hosts' perspective on Dean Corll's actions being labeled as "homosexual"?
The hosts strongly argue that Dean Corll was a pedophile, not simply homosexual. They emphasize that his attraction was to children, regardless of his sexual orientation, and that labeling him solely as homosexual misrepresents the nature of his crimes.
What updates are provided regarding Dean Corll's accomplices?
In 2020, David Brooks died in prison from COVID-19. Elmer Henley has been repeatedly denied parole, with his most recent denial in November 2025.
What was the motive behind the murder of Larry Austin at the Silent Movie Theater?
James Van Sickle, Larry Austin's lover and the contractor who renovated the theater, hired Christian Rodriguez to kill Austin. Van Sickle was motivated by Austin's inheritance of the theater, which was valued at over a million dollars, and his own significant debts.
Who was Christian Rodriguez and what was his role in the crime?
Christian Rodriguez was a 19-year-old hired by James Van Sickle to murder Larry Austin and make it look like a robbery. He shot Austin multiple times and also shot Mary Giles, a concession stand worker, twice in the chest.
Show Notes
It's time to Rewind with Karen & Georgia!
This week, K & G recap Episode 89: The Finch. Georgia covered serial killer Dean Corll and Karen told the story of the Silent Movie Theater Murder. Tune in for all-new commentary, case updates and more!
Whether you've listened a thousand times or you're new to the show, join the conversation as we look back on our old episodes and discuss the life lessons we’ve learned along the way. Head to social media to share your favorite moments from this episode!
Instagram: instagram.com/myfavoritemurder
Facebook: facebook.com/myfavoritemurder
TikTok: tiktok.com/@my_favorite_murder
Now with updated sources and photos: https://www.myfavoritemurder.com/episodes
My Favorite Murder is a true crime comedy podcast hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark. Each week, Karen and Georgia share compelling true crimes and hometown stories from friends and listeners. Since MFM launched in January 2016, Karen and Georgia have shared their lifelong interest in true crime and have covered stories of infamous serial killers like the Night Stalker, mysterious cold cases, captivating cults, incredible survivor stories and important events from history like the Tulsa race massacre of 1921.
The Exactly Right podcast network provides a platform for bold, creative voices to bring to life provocative, entertaining and relatable stories for audiences everywhere. The Exactly Right roster of podcasts covers a variety of topics, including true crime, comedy, science, pop culture and more. Podcasts on the network include Buried Bones with Kate Winkler Dawson and Paul Holes, That's Messed Up: An SVU Podcast, This Podcast Will Kill You, Bananas and more.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Table of contents
United States
