DiscoverMonsters Among UsS18 Ep51: A wildman, a wolfman and a mermaid: Hometown Legends 18 Part II (Sn. 18 Ep. 51)
S18 Ep51: A wildman, a wolfman and a mermaid: Hometown Legends 18 Part II (Sn. 18 Ep. 51)

S18 Ep51: A wildman, a wolfman and a mermaid: Hometown Legends 18 Part II (Sn. 18 Ep. 51)

Update: 2025-04-10
Share

Digest

This podcast episode features a collection of "Hometown Legends" submitted by listeners, covering diverse locations and unexplained phenomena. Stories range from ghostly encounters at the Grand Theatre and Ward Robert's Public School in Canada, to the paranormal activity reported near the Mameyes landslide ruins in Puerto Rico. The episode also includes accounts of a mysterious moving drink at Chicago's Excalibur Nightclub linked to the SS Eastland disaster, the West Virginia Blue Devil cryptid, and the discovery of an opium den in Idaho. Other stories detail a figure sighted on California's Snake Road, an investigation of the Loftus House in West Virginia, and the legends of the Orford Wildman in England and Cape Fear mermaids in North Carolina. Listener submissions also include a mysterious baby's cry at Pacific View Mall and the legend of Dudley Town in Connecticut. The podcast balances the presentation of these stories with a respectful approach, acknowledging both the emotional impact and the need for critical examination, often incorporating historical context and research to verify information.

Outlines

00:03:53
Canadian & Puerto Rican Ghost Stories and Tragic Events

Annabelle shares ghostly encounters at the Grand Theatre and Ward Robert's Public School in Canada, while Liz recounts the 1985 Mameyes landslide tragedy in Ponce, Puerto Rico, and subsequent paranormal activity at the Intercontinental Hotel ruins.

00:22:28
Chicago, West Virginia, and Idaho Mysteries

Tony shares a mysterious experience at Chicago's Excalibur Nightclub linked to the SS Eastland disaster; Dawn discusses the West Virginia Blue Devil cryptid; and Mikey shares stories about a Chinese cemetery and opium den in Idaho.

00:54:21
California, West Virginia, and England/North Carolina Legends

Aaron recounts a sighting on California's Snake Road; Eric shares his investigation of the Loftus House in West Virginia; and Fraser and Jay discuss the Orford Wildman in England and Cape Fear mermaids in North Carolina.

01:33:27
Listener Stories: Pacific View Mall and Dudley Town

A listener shares a story of a baby's cry at Pacific View Mall, and Connor recounts the legend of Dudley Town in Connecticut.

Keywords

Hometown Legends


Local stories and myths passed down through generations, often involving supernatural elements or historical events.

Cryptid


A creature whose existence is not proven but is supported by anecdotal evidence.

Paranormal


Events or phenomena beyond normal scientific understanding.

Urban Legend


A widely circulated story, often fictional, believed to be based on fact.

Haunted Locations


Places believed to be inhabited by ghosts or spirits.

Mameyes Landslide


A devastating 1985 mudslide in Ponce, Puerto Rico.

SS Eastland Disaster


The 1915 capsizing of the SS Eastland steamship in Chicago.

Blue Devil (West Virginia Cryptid)


A large, bluish, dog-like creature from West Virginia folklore.

Pacific View Mall


A former shopping mall in Ventura, California, featured in a listener's story.

Dudley Town


A location in Cornwall, Connecticut, associated with a mysterious legend.

Q&A

  • What is the significance of the children's drawings preceding the Mameyes landslide?

    The drawings seem to depict elements of the disaster, raising questions about precognitive abilities.

  • How does the podcast approach the stories, balancing skepticism and belief?

    The podcast presents stories respectfully, acknowledging both emotional impact and the need for critical examination.

  • What are some common themes in the "Hometown Legends" stories?

    Common themes include tragic events, haunted locations, unexplained phenomena, and the enduring power of local folklore.

  • How does the podcast verify the information shared by listeners?

    The podcast uses listener accounts, historical research, and fact-checking to verify information.

  • What is the purpose of including listener stories in the podcast?

    Listener stories provide diverse experiences and perspectives, making the podcast engaging and relatable.

  • What is the main theme of this podcast episode?

    The episode focuses on listener-submitted hometown legends from different locations.

  • What is the story behind the baby's crying at Pacific View Mall?

    A listener's sister and coworkers heard a baby crying from within the stockroom walls, a sound that persisted despite investigations.

  • What is the legend of Dudley Town?

    Dudley Town is said to be haunted and associated with a family's history tracing back to a beheading in 1510 England.

Show Notes

Tonight we dive even deeper into your hair-raising hometown legends, including frightening folklore about creatures that lurk in the darkness, unsettling hauntings, mermaids and more.



Season 18 Episode 51 of Monsters Among Us Podcast, true paranormal stories of ghosts, cryptids, UFOs and more, told by the witnesses themselves.



SHOW NOTES: 



Support the show! Get ad-free, extended & bonus episodes (and more) on Patreon - https://www.patreon.com/monstersamonguspodcast



Tonight's Sponsor - UpWork - Visit Upwork.com to post your job for free and connect with top talent ready to help your business grow.



Tonight's Sponsor - VIIA hemp gummies - If you're 21+, visit VIIAhemp.com and use code MAU to take advantage of their Spring 420 Sale, you'll find Black Friday level savings, up to 35% off sitewide, and 50% off packs and bundles. Plus use code MAU for a free gift + more savings with your first order and free shipping on orders over $100.



Believing the Bizarre Podcast - https://believingthebizarre.com/



MAU Merch Shop - https://www.monstersamonguspodcast.com/shop



Watch FREE - Shadows in the Desert: High Strangeness in the Borrego Triangle  - https://www.borregotriangle.com/



Monsters Among Us Junior on Apple Podcasts  - https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/monsters-among-us-junior/id1764989478



Monsters Among Us Junior on Spotify -

https://open.spotify.com/show/1bh5mWa4lDSqeMMX1mYxDZ?si=9ec6f4f74d61498b



The Mameyes Landslide Drawings -  https://ylafamilia.org/the-mameyes-landslide/  



Coverage of the Mameyes tragedy - https://shorturl.at/ECbEE  



SS Eastland Tragedy - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SS_Eastland



SS Eastland News Coverage - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zuPjb58Ne_I



Haunted Harpo Studios - https://mysteriouschicago.com/the-hauntings-of-harpo-studios/



Blue Devil Dogman - https://theclio.com/entry/85665



Lake Arrowhead Underwater Trains - https://blogs.chapman.edu/huell-howser-archives/2000/01/08/under-lake-arrowhead-californias-gold-2011/



(Snake Road Article) Young Girl Is Brutally Beaten By 3 Bandits -  https://shorturl.at/8frXZ 



(Snake Road Article) Death Rides Canyon Roadm - https://shorturl.at/u3bUS 



(Snake Road Article) A. Schlueter Found Shot Dead By Auto - https://shorturl.at/TRQHj 



(Snake Road Article) Suicides In Auto at Lone Moraga Spot - https://shorturl.at/0BhTF 



(Snake Road Article) Stray Bullet Thought to Have Killed Man -  https://shorturl.at/0whMv 



(Snake Road Article) Carjacking suspect arrested after chase - https://shorturl.at/FYrHx (



(Snake Road Article) Woman critically hurt in beating, police say - https://shorturl.at/GqZIq 



(Snake Road Article) Deputy in chase overturns patrol car - https://shorturl.at/fgaVU 



(Snake Road Article) Police seek to ID fatally injured cyclist - https://shorturl.at/Wfgk5



Ohio's Loftus House - https://www.ohioexploration.com/paranormal/hauntings/jeffersoncounty/



Ireland's Loftus Hall - https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=1639158783606888



Orford Castle -- and a merman - https://bitaboutbritain.com/orford-castle-and-a-merman/ 



Cape Fear Mermaids - https://www.wral.com/story/mermaid-point-legend-of-mermaids-in-the-cape-fear-dates-back-to-the-revolutionary-war/20175311/



Christopher Columbus Mermaid/Manatee Mixup - https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/january-9/columbus-mistakes-manatees-for-mermaids



Marshall Mermaid Parade Ad - https://www.instagram.com/madison_county_nc/reel/C7U7HuDvMxE/



Marshall Mermaid Parade Info - https://exploremarshallnc.com/mermaid-parade-and-festival/



Pacific View Mall Info - http://bit.ly/3E0vBii





Music from tonight's episode:



Music by Iron Cthulhu Apocalypse - https://www.youtube.com/c/IronCthulhuApocalypse



CO.AG Music - https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcavSftXHgxLBWwLDm_bNvA



Music by White Bat Audio - https://www.youtube.com/@WhiteBatAudio



White Bat Audio Songs:

Behind the Shadows

Is Anyone Left

Cryptid

Prey

Crypt Dweller
Comments 
loading
In Channel
loading

Table of contents

00:00
00:00
1.0x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

S18 Ep51: A wildman, a wolfman and a mermaid: Hometown Legends 18 Part II (Sn. 18 Ep. 51)

S18 Ep51: A wildman, a wolfman and a mermaid: Hometown Legends 18 Part II (Sn. 18 Ep. 51)

Derek Hayes | Audioboom Studios