Scott Sumner and Noah Smith Debate the China Question
Digest
This podcast features a debate between economists Scott Sumner and Noah Smith on the effectiveness and implications of industrial policy. Smith advocates for industrial policy, particularly to counter China's manufacturing dominance and address national security concerns, emphasizing its role in driving down the cost of green technologies. Sumner, a more neoliberal economist, expresses skepticism, highlighting potential inefficiencies and the importance of free markets. Their discussion covers various aspects, including the historical context of industrial policy in East Asian economies, the challenges of evaluating its impact, and the role of deregulation. The debate also touches upon the US-China relationship, the China threat, and the use of economic warfare, with differing views on the importance of manufacturing capacity and the effectiveness of various policy approaches. Specific policies like the Trump administration's tariffs and the Biden administration's Chips Act and Inflation Reduction Act are analyzed, showcasing contrasting outcomes. Ultimately, the podcast highlights the complexities and lack of easy answers surrounding industrial policy, emphasizing the need for careful consideration of its potential benefits and drawbacks.
Outlines
Industrial Policy: A US-China Perspective
Economists debate the merits of industrial policy, focusing on its application to climate change and US-China relations, highlighting differing views on effectiveness and the China threat. This includes discussions of arguments for and against industrial policy, its role in green technology development, and the challenges of evaluating its impact.
Economists' Perspectives and the Debate Framework
Sumner and Smith introduce their backgrounds and perspectives, setting the stage for their debate. Sumner identifies as a monetary economist and unreconstructed neoliberal, while Smith is an econ writer and generalist.
Industrial Policy, Climate Change, and National Security
The discussion shifts to climate change and national security, exploring the application of industrial policy to combat climate change and the role of manufacturing capacity in US-China relations. This includes discussions on China's role in green technology, the effectiveness of economic warfare, and the importance of deterrence.
Deregulation and the Future of Industrial Policy
The conversation explores deregulation as a potential form of industrial policy, particularly in areas like housing and healthcare, to improve working-class living standards. The debate concludes with a discussion on the US-China relationship and the effectiveness of economic warfare.
Keywords
Industrial Policy
Government intervention in the economy to promote specific industries; its effectiveness is debated.
US-China Relations
The complex relationship between the US and China, encompassing economic, political, and military dimensions.
Neoliberalism
A political-economic philosophy emphasizing free markets and deregulation.
Comparative Advantage
A country's ability to produce goods or services at a lower opportunity cost.
Climate Change
The long-term shift in global temperatures and weather patterns; industrial policy's role in mitigation.
National Security
The protection of a nation's interests from external threats; the role of industrial policy.
Economic Warfare
The use of economic tools to exert pressure on another country.
Dual-Use Technology
Technology with both civilian and military applications.
Deregulation
The reduction or elimination of government regulations.
Q&A
What are the main arguments for and against implementing industrial policy, particularly in the context of US-China relations?
Proponents cite national security concerns and the need to boost domestic production; opponents highlight potential inefficiencies and the importance of free markets.
How does the debate on industrial policy intersect with the issue of climate change?
Differing views exist on using industrial policy to promote green technologies, with some arguing China's policies have inadvertently lowered green tech costs.
What is the role of manufacturing capacity in the context of US-China relations and national security?
Manufacturing capacity, especially for dual-use technologies, is crucial for military deterrence against China, though there's disagreement on its overall importance.
How do differing economic philosophies, such as neoliberalism, influence the debate on industrial policy?
Neoliberalism's emphasis on free markets contrasts with the interventionist approach of industrial policy; the discussion explores whether these are mutually exclusive.
What are some specific examples of industrial policies that have been implemented, and what have been their outcomes?
The podcast discusses the Trump tariffs (largely ineffective) and the Biden administration's Chips Act and Inflation Reduction Act (showing early signs of success).
Show Notes
As China surges past the combined manufacturing might of Western democracies, economists Scott Sumner and Noah Smith square off on America's industrial future. While agreeing on economic fundamentals, they clash over the gravity of China's rise - Sumner advocating measured engagement while Smith warns of an unprecedented shift in global power requiring bold policy action.
—
📰 Be notified early when Turpentine's drops new publication: https://www.turpentine.co/exclusiveaccess
🙏 Help shape our show by taking our quick listener survey at https://bit.ly/TurpentinePulse
—
SPONSOR: ORACLE | NETSUITE | SHOPIFY | ADQUICK
☁️ Oracle Cloud Infrastructure (OCI) is a single platform for your infrastructure, database, application development, and AI needs. OCI has four to eight times the bandwidth of other clouds and offers one consistent price. Oracle is offering to cut your cloud bill in half. See if your company qualifies at https://oracle.com/turpentine/
Over 41,000 businesses trust NetSuite by Oracle, the #1 cloud ERP, to future-proof their operations. With a unified platform for accounting, financial management, inventory, and HR, NetSuite provides real-time insights and forecasting to help you make quick, informed decisions. Whether you're earning millions or hundreds of millions, NetSuite empowers you to tackle challenges and seize opportunities. Download the free CFO's guide to AI and machine learning at https://netsuite.com/zen.
Shopify is the world's leading e-commerce platform, offering a market-leading checkout system Shoppay and exclusive AI apps. Nobody does selling better than Shopify. Get a $1 per month trial at https://shopify.com/momentofzen
Say goodbye to the headaches of out-of-home advertising. AdQuick combines technology, OOH expertise, and data to enable efficient, seamless ad buying across the globe. Visit https://adquick.com/ to start reaching your customers in the real world.
—
RECOMMENDED PODCAST:
Check out Modern Relationships, where Erik Torenberg interviews tech power couples and leading thinkers to explore how ambitious people actually make partnerships work. This season's guests include: Delian Asparouhov & Nadia Asparouhova, Kristen Berman & Phil Levin, Rob Henderson, and Liv Boeree & Igor Kurganov.
Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/id1786227593
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/5hJzs0gDg6lRT6r10mdpVg
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ModernRelationshipsPod
—
HIGHLIGHTS:
Core Agreement Areas:
- Both are skeptical of partisan justifications for industrial policy (Democrats' "good jobs" focus and Republicans' "America First" stance)
- Both agree liberalization, not industrial policy, drove China's rapid growth
Climate Change & Green Tech:
- Sumner argues Biden's green subsidies were undermined by trade barriers against Chinese EVs/solar
- Smith counters that China's industrial policy in green tech has actually helped global climate goals by scaling production and reducing costs
Central Point of Disagreement - China Threat:
- Sumner sees Russia as the bigger immediate threat and warns against needlessly antagonizing China
- Smith argues we've entered a new era where China's manufacturing dominance (especially in military-relevant technologies like drones and batteries) fundamentally threatens democratic nations
Biden vs Trump Policy Results:
- Both criticize Trump's tariffs as ineffective
- Smith points to success of Biden's CHIPS Act and IRA in boosting domestic manufacturing of critical technologies
- Sumner suggests many industrial policies are based on misconceptions about macroeconomics
Manufacturing Strategy:
- Sumner advocates addressing trade deficits through fiscal policy and savings rates
- Smith emphasizes the need to maintain manufacturing parity in specific dual-use technologies
- They differ on whether total manufacturing capacity or specific industrial capabilities matter more for national security
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Table of contents
United States
