Scouting Every AL East No. 1 Prospect For 2026
Digest
This podcast series, Baseball America Prospect Profiles, features discussions on top prospects across various MLB organizations. The episode highlights pitcher Treya Savage of the Blue Jays, analyzing his unique delivery and postseason performance. It then explores other Blue Jays prospects like Jojo Parker and Arjun Namala. The focus shifts to Red Sox pitcher Peyton Toley, discussing his rapid development and potential. Yankees shortstop prospects George Lombard Jr. and Dax Kilby are examined, contrasting Lombard's defense with Kilby's offensive upside. The Orioles' top prospect, catcher Samuel Basio, is profiled for his power and hitting ability. Finally, Rays pitcher Brodie Hopkins is discussed, noting his transition from outfielder and his exceptional curveball. The series aims to provide in-depth analysis of these emerging talents.
Outlines

Introduction and Blue Jays Prospect: Treya Savage
JJ Cooper and Jeff Ponce introduce the Baseball America Prospect Profiles series, focusing on top prospects. Today's discussion centers on pitcher Treya Savage of the Blue Jays, analyzing his impressive postseason performance, unique pitch mix, arm slot, and delivery.

Blue Jays and Red Sox Prospects: Depth and Potential
The conversation shifts to other promising prospects within the Blue Jays organization, including shortstops Jojo Parker and Arjun Namala, and pitchers Johnny King, Ricky Tiedemann, and Gage Stanifer, highlighting the system's depth. The focus then moves to Red Sox starting pitcher Peyton Toley, discussing his rapid development, impressive fastball velocity, unique release point, and secondary pitches.

Yankees and Orioles Prospects: Shortstop and Catcher Talent
The discussion shifts to the Yankees' shortstop prospects, George Lombard Jr. and Dax Kilby. Lombard's polish and defensive prowess are contrasted with questions about his offensive production, while Kilby's immediate impact and high upside are highlighted. The profile then focuses on the Baltimore Orioles' number one prospect, Samuel Basio, discussing his exceptional power, hitting ability, and potential as an offensive catcher.

Rays Pitcher Prospect: Brodie Hopkins
The final prospect profile examines Brodie Hopkins, a pitcher for the Tampa Bay Rays. His unique journey from outfielder to pitcher, his outlier curveball, and his athletic traits are discussed, along with his potential ETA and development path.
Keywords
Treya Savage
A rookie pitcher for the Blue Jays known for his unusual delivery, pitch mix, and high-level performance. His long-term viability and potential as a front-line starter are key discussion points.
Peyton Toley
A rising starting pitcher prospect for the Red Sox with exceptional fastball velocity and promising secondary pitches, positioning him as a potential top-of-the-rotation arm.
George Lombard Jr.
A polished shortstop prospect for the Yankees, lauded for his defense and plate discipline, with ongoing evaluation of his offensive production.
Dax Kilby
A promising Yankees shortstop prospect known for his immediate offensive impact and high upside, indicated by strong athletic testing.
Samuel Basio
The top prospect for the Baltimore Orioles, a catcher with exceptional power and hitting ability, with ongoing evaluation of his defensive capabilities.
Brodie Hopkins
A pitching prospect for the Tampa Bay Rays who transitioned from outfielder, noted for his unique curveball and athletic traits.
Prospect Profiles
A series focusing on top prospects within Major League Baseball organizations, analyzing their skills, potential, and projected career paths.
Pitch Mix
The variety of pitches a pitcher throws, including their speed, movement, and effectiveness, a key factor in pitcher analysis.
Arm Slot
The angle and release point from which a pitcher throws the ball, with unusual arm slots like Treya Savage's creating unique challenges for hitters.
Release Height
The vertical distance from the ground at which a pitcher releases the ball, contributing to pitch deception and movement.
Q&A
What makes Treya Savage's pitching delivery unusual?
Treya Savage has an unusual arm slot that creates significant ride on his fastball, despite a high release height. His delivery also involves his back being towards the batter initially, making the ball difficult to pick up.
What are the main concerns regarding Peyton Toley's long-term potential?
While Toley possesses an elite fastball and promising secondary pitches, the primary question revolves around the development and consistency of his secondary offerings to become a reliable major league starter.
Why is George Lombard Jr.'s upcoming season considered crucial?
Lombard has consistently been a polished defender with good plate discipline, but scouts and analysts are waiting for a breakout season in terms of offensive production to match his high prospect status.
What is the biggest question surrounding Samuel Basio's future?
The primary question for Samuel Basio is his long-term durability and effectiveness as a catcher. While his offensive potential is immense, his ability to consistently handle the demands of the position will determine his ultimate ceiling.
How does Brodie Hopkins' curveball stand out?
Brodie Hopkins throws an outlier curveball with exceptional velocity (around 90 mph) and significant downward movement, which is highly unusual for a pitch of that speed and type, making it difficult for hitters to adjust to.
What is the significance of Dax Kilby's athletic testing?
Kilby's performance at the draft combine in terms of exit velocity (EVs) and athletic testing indicated significant raw power and athleticism, suggesting a high upside potential that the Yankees can work to optimize.
What factors contribute to the Rays' success in developing pitchers like Brodie Hopkins?
The Rays excel at helping pitchers maximize control and command, often encouraging them to throw to the middle of the zone. Their belief in developing athleticism also aids pitchers in repeating their delivery and improving command.
Show Notes
We're going deep on each of the top prospects in the AL East. The guys explain how each respective player climbed to No. 1 in their system, run through their scouting reports and lay out what you should expect in 2026.
Time Stamps
(0:00 ) -- Trey Yesavage, Blue Jays
(9:35 ) -- Payton Tolle, Red Sox
(17:55 ) -- George Lombard Jr., Yankees
(26:30 ) -- Samuel Basallo, Orioles
(35:00 ) -- Brody Hopkins, Rays
Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.com
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy



