DiscoverMrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious StoriesThe Life of the Party (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)
The Life of the Party (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)

The Life of the Party (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)

Update: 2024-09-027
Share

Digest

The podcast delves into the perplexing death of Nancy Fister, a prominent figure in Aspen's social circles. The story begins with Nancy hosting a farewell party before her planned trip to Australia. However, her life takes a tragic turn when she is found dead in her own home. The police launch an investigation, interviewing Nancy's friend Kathy, who discovered the body, and Tray and his wife, who were renting Nancy's house. Suspicion falls upon Kathy, who appears to be withholding information, and Tray and his wife, who had a strained relationship with Nancy. Key evidence, including Nancy's missing pills and her closet key, is found near the hotel where Tray and his wife were staying. Tray eventually confesses to killing Nancy, claiming he acted alone. He describes the murder in detail, including how he hit her with a hammer, dragged her body to the closet, and wrapped her in trash bags and bedding. Further investigation reveals that Tray and his wife had a falling out with Nancy over rent payments, expressing anger and wishing her dead. The police conclude that Tray, his wife, and Kathy were involved in Nancy's murder. However, Tray confesses to acting alone, and his wife and Kathy are released. Tray is sentenced to 20 years in prison but later commits suicide.

Outlines

00:00:10
The Mysterious Death of Nancy Fister

This chapter introduces the story of Nancy Fister, a wealthy socialite in Aspen, Colorado, who was found dead in her own home. The story begins with her hosting a farewell party before heading to Australia.

00:01:01
The Investigation Begins

After Nancy's body is discovered, the police begin their investigation. They interview Kathy, Nancy's friend who found the body, and Tray and his wife, who were renting Nancy's house.

00:19:05
The Suspects and Evidence

The police suspect Kathy, who seems to be hiding information, and Tray and his wife, who had a strained relationship with Nancy. They find key evidence, including Nancy's missing pills and her closet key, near the hotel where Tray and his wife were staying.

00:33:17
The Confession and the Motive

Tray confesses to killing Nancy, claiming he acted alone. He describes the murder in detail, including how he hit her with a hammer, dragged her body to the closet, and wrapped her in trash bags and bedding. The police investigate further and discover that Tray and his wife had a falling out with Nancy over rent payments. They had expressed anger towards Nancy and wished she was dead.

00:38:01
The Verdict and Aftermath

The police conclude that Tray, his wife, and Kathy were involved in Nancy's murder. However, Tray confesses to acting alone, and his wife and Kathy are released. Tray is sentenced to 20 years in prison but later commits suicide.

Keywords

Aspen Royalty


A group of wealthy individuals in Aspen, Colorado, known for their lavish lifestyles and exclusive social circles. They often exhibit snobbish attitudes and maintain a sense of superiority over those outside their social class.

Medical Mystery


A puzzling or unexplained medical case that defies conventional diagnosis or explanation. These cases often involve unusual symptoms, rare diseases, or unexpected outcomes, challenging medical professionals to unravel the underlying cause.

Blunt Force Trauma


An injury caused by a forceful impact or blow to the body, often resulting in bruising, lacerations, or fractures. It is a common cause of death in accidents, assaults, and falls.

Crime of Passion


A crime, typically murder, committed in a state of intense emotion, often driven by jealousy, anger, or revenge. It is often characterized by impulsivity and a lack of premeditation.

Jolt of Adrenaline


A sudden surge of adrenaline, a hormone released by the adrenal glands in response to stress or excitement. It can cause a range of physical and psychological effects, including increased heart rate, blood pressure, and alertness.

Q&A

  • What was the cause of Nancy Fister's death?

    Nancy Fister was murdered by blunt force trauma to the head, likely inflicted with a hammer.

  • Who was initially suspected of killing Nancy Fister?

    Kathy, Nancy's friend who found the body, was initially suspected because she seemed to be hiding information and knew details about the murder scene that she shouldn't have known.

  • What evidence led the police to believe that Tray Styler was the killer?

    The police found Nancy's missing pills and her closet key near the hotel where Tray and his wife were staying. They also discovered that Tray and his wife had a heated argument with Nancy over rent payments and had expressed anger towards her.

  • Why did Tray Styler confess to the murder?

    Tray confessed to killing Nancy, claiming he acted alone. He said he experienced a surge of adrenaline that made him feel capable of carrying out the murder.

  • What happened to Tray Styler after his confession?

    Tray was sentenced to 20 years in prison but later committed suicide in his cell.

Show Notes

On a winter morning in 2014, a woman walked through a massive two-story house in the beautiful ski town of Aspen, Colorado. She had come to see her friend, who’d just gotten back from a long vacation. The woman walked into the bedroom, but her friend wasn’t there. She called out, but there was no response. So she walked across the room and opened the door to a huge walk-in closet that her friend had transformed into a meditation room. The woman saw prayer flags hanging from the wall and candles spread out across the room. She glanced down and saw a pile of blankets and sheets on the floor. At first, she didn’t think anything about it – maybe her friend laid on the blankets and sheets when she was meditating. But as the woman turned to go, something caught her eye. She leaned down, looked closer at the blankets, and screamed. Beneath the blankets, she saw strands of her friend’s long blonde hair soaked in blood. With her hands shaking, she grabbed her phone and called the police. She told them that one of the richest and most well known women in Aspen had been murdered.


For 100s more stories like these, check out our main YouTube channel just called "MrBallen" -- https://www.youtube.com/c/MrBallen

If you want to reach out to me, contact me on Instagram, Twitter or any other major social media platform, my username on all of them is @mrballen

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Comments 
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

The Life of the Party (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)

The Life of the Party (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)