True Crime Time For April 11, 2026 | Gilgo Beach Killer Pleads Guilty, Insurance Murder Plot, Toy Box Killer Case
Digest
This podcast delves into a series of compelling true crime cases. It begins with the tragic and unsolved murders of the Sharp family in 1981, where an 11-year-old discovered her murdered mother and brother. The investigation then shifts to the Gilgo Beach serial killer case, focusing on architect Rex Heuermann, who pleaded guilty to killing seven women. Another case explored is Joshua Hunsucker, a former paramedic accused of poisoning his wife with eyedrops for insurance money. The podcast also recounts a high-speed, wrong-way chase in Alabama involving a suspect with numerous prior arrests and four children in the vehicle. Further cases include David Ray Parker, the "Toy Box" serial rapist, and the shooting death of New Orleans social media personality Boogie B., where the convicted shooter received a 15-year sentence. Finally, the episode touches on the arrest of rapper Poo Shiesty for armed robbery and kidnapping at a Dallas music studio.
Outlines
Unsolved Murders and Serial Killers
This section covers the unsolved murders of the Sharp family in 1981, where a young girl discovered her murdered mother and brother, and her sister went missing. It also details the Gilgo Beach serial killer case, focusing on architect Rex Heuermann, who pleaded guilty to killing seven women, and David Ray Parker, the "Toy Box" serial rapist known for his torture chamber.
Poisoning, Chases, and Studio Robbery
This part of the podcast discusses Joshua Hunsucker, a former paramedic accused of poisoning his wife with eyedrops. It also recounts a high-speed, wrong-way chase in Alabama involving a suspect with many prior arrests and children in the car. Additionally, it covers the arrest of rapper Poo Shiesty and associates for armed robbery and kidnapping at a Dallas music studio.
Tragic Shootings and Their Aftermath
This chapter focuses on the shooting death of New Orleans social media personality Boogie B., who was an innocent bystander. The convicted shooter received a 15-year sentence, while another alleged gunman faces trial.
Keywords
Sharp Family Murders
The unsolved murders of a family in 1981, discovered by an 11-year-old girl, with a missing sister whose remains were found years later.
Rex Heuermann
Architect charged and pleaded guilty to killing seven women, with remains found along Long Island's Gilgo Beach.
Joshua Hunsucker
Former paramedic accused of poisoning his wife with eyedrops for life insurance money and staging his own kidnapping.
Alabama High-Speed Chase
A dangerous wrong-way pursuit involving a suspect with numerous prior arrests and four children in the vehicle.
David Ray Parker
Known as the "Toy Box" serial rapist, he used a soundproofed trailer as a torture chamber; one victim's escape led to his capture.
Boogie B. Shooting
The death of a New Orleans social media personality as an innocent bystander in a shootout, resulting in a 15-year sentence for the convicted shooter.
Poo Shiesty Arrest
Rapper arrested for armed robbery and kidnapping at a Dallas music studio, allegedly forcing victims at gunpoint.
Q&A
Who is Rex Heuermann and what was he convicted of?
Rex Heuermann is an architect who pleaded guilty to the murders of seven women. Their remains were discovered along Long Island's Gilgo Beach, and he admitted to strangling each victim.
How did Joshua Hunsucker allegedly kill his wife?
Prosecutors allege Joshua Hunsucker used eyedrops containing tetrahydrozoline to poison his wife, Stacy, over an extended period. He then allegedly lied about her cause of death to collect on a life insurance policy.
What led to the arrest of the suspects in the Alabama chase?
The suspects were apprehended after law enforcement deployed spike strips, disabling their vehicle. They then fled on foot but were quickly caught. The chase involved four children and a suspect with a long criminal history.
How did authorities uncover David Ray Parker's crimes?
One of Parker's victims, Cynthia Vigil, managed to escape from his torture chamber. Her escape and subsequent report to the police led investigators to discover the horrific extent of his crimes.
What was the outcome of the shooting death of Boogie B.?
Charles Cannon, convicted in the shooting death of Boogie B., was sentenced to 15 years. Boogie B. was an innocent bystander. Another alleged gunman is awaiting trial for second-degree murder.
What were the charges against Poo Shiesty and his associates?
Rapper Poo Shiesty and eight others face charges including kidnapping and armed robbery. They allegedly held music industry professionals at gunpoint in a Dallas studio, forcing contract releases and stealing valuables.
Show Notes
In this episode of True Crime Time For, Woody Overton delivers a powerful and emotional breakdown of major cases spanning decades — from long-awaited justice to some of the darkest crimes ever uncovered.
The episode begins with a historic update in the Gilgo Beach serial killer case, where Rex Heuermann pleads guilty to multiple murders, finally bringing answers to families after years of uncertainty. The chilling details of the crimes — including strangulation and calculated planning — highlight the calculated nature of serial offenders.
Woody then shifts into a disturbing case out of North Carolina, where a man is accused of poisoning his wife using eye drops to collect life insurance money. The case takes an even darker turn when it’s revealed he later staged his own kidnapping and attempted to manipulate investigators.
The episode also dives into one of the most horrifying criminal cases ever documented — the Toy Box Killer, a sadistic predator who kidnapped and tortured victims in a custom-built chamber. The story serves as a stark reminder of the depths of human evil and the importance of survivor testimony.
Additional cases include:
- A dangerous multi-state police chase involving children inside the suspect vehicle
- A tragic case involving New Orleans comedian Boogie B, killed as an innocent bystander
- A federal case involving rapper Pooh Shiesty and a coordinated armed robbery and kidnapping scheme
Throughout the episode, Woody reinforces a central message: justice takes time, but it does come — and community awareness plays a critical role in getting there.
🎧 Chapters
00:00 Introduction and Madison Case Update
02:00 This Day in History – Keddie Cabin Murders
06:00 Gilgo Beach Serial Killer Pleads Guilty
14:00 Details of Victims and Investigation
20:00 Family Matters: Eye Drop Poisoning Murder Case
27:00 Insurance Fraud and Staged Kidnapping
32:00 Alabama High-Speed Chase with Children
38:00 Toy Box Killer Case Breakdown
52:00 New Orleans Boogie B Shooting Case
58:00 F’ed Up Professionals: Pooh Shiesty Federal Case
01:08:00 Closing Thoughts and Call to Action
true crime, Gilgo Beach serial killer, Rex Heuermann guilty plea, Long Island serial killer case, eye drops poisoning murder case, North Carolina murder case, insurance fraud homicide, Toy Box Killer case, serial killer torture chamber, New Mexico crime case, police chase with children, Alabama police chase case, Boogie B shooting New Orleans, innocent bystander shooting, Pooh Shiesty arrest case, federal kidnapping case, crime news 2026, law enforcement investigations, justice for victims, true crime podcast
If you’re struggling with OCD or unrelenting intrusive thoughts, NOCD can help. Book a free 15 minute call to get started: https://learn.nocd.com/RLRC
Our Sponsors:
* Check out Hers: https://forhers.com/rlrc
* Check out Mood and use my code RLRC for a great deal: https://mood.com
* Check out Ruggable and use my code RLRC for a great deal: https://ruggable.com
* If you’re struggling with OCD or unrelenting intrusive thoughts, NOCD can help. Book a free 15 minute call to get started: https://learn.nocd.com/RLRC
Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/real-life-real-crime/donations
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Table of contents
United States
