DiscoverThe Political Scene | The New YorkerWhat Does It Mean to Resist Trump in 2025?
What Does It Mean to Resist Trump in 2025?

What Does It Mean to Resist Trump in 2025?

Update: 2025-02-132
Share

Digest

This podcast delves into the concept of "resistance" in the context of Donald Trump's presidency, contrasting the widespread social and cultural dissent during his first term with the perceived lack of similar resistance in his second term. It explores the reasons behind this shift, including the Democratic Party's response and the changing nature of cultural resistance. The podcast defines "resistance" as a multifaceted phenomenon encompassing both cultural and political aspects, distinguishing between the "hashtag resistance" of 2016 and the more traditional political resistance. It examines the evolution of cultural resistance, noting a shift from intense activism to a more fragmented and less visible form, exploring the reasons for this shift, including the perceived need to return to normalcy and the lack of a shared vision on the left. The podcast discusses the ongoing relevance of cultural resistance in the face of a Trump administration that actively defies democracy, acknowledging the challenges of defining a unified cultural resistance in the current media landscape and exploring the role of celebrities and public figures in shaping public opinion. It analyzes the Super Bowl as a microcosm of the current cultural moment, highlighting the juxtaposition of Trump's presence at the game with Kendrick Lamar's politically charged halftime performance. The podcast examines the potential cultural shift towards Trump, analyzing the role of celebrities and public figures in shaping public opinion, discussing the rise of podcasting and social media influencers as new forms of celebrity and their potential impact on political discourse. It analyzes Joe Rogan's political transformation from a loose centrist to a figure aligned with the far right, exploring the reasons behind this shift, including Rogan's anti-establishment ideology, his experiences during the COVID-19 pandemic, and his growing influence on a large audience. The podcast examines the Democratic Party's challenges in the face of Trump's second term, discussing the party's reliance on the "threat to democracy" narrative and the potential pitfalls of this strategy. It also explores the need for Democrats to develop a more concrete and compelling vision for the future. The podcast explores the emergence of new political leaders like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who are utilizing social media platforms to connect with constituents and promote a more progressive vision for America. It discusses the potential for these leaders to resonate with younger voters and challenge the traditional political establishment. The podcast highlights the contradictions within the Democratic Party, particularly regarding its reliance on wealthy donors while advocating for anti-capitalist policies. It explores the challenges of navigating these contradictions and the need for Democrats to address them in a more authentic and consistent manner.

Outlines

00:00:00
The Evolution of Resistance in the Trump Era

This podcast explores the evolution of cultural resistance in the Trump era, analyzing its shift from widespread activism to a more fragmented form, examining the role of celebrities and public figures in shaping public opinion, and discussing the challenges facing the Democratic Party in the face of Trump's second term.

00:01:04
Defining Resistance: Cultural vs. Political

The podcast defines "resistance" as a multifaceted phenomenon encompassing both cultural and political aspects, distinguishing between the "hashtag resistance" of 2016 and the more traditional political resistance. It examines the evolution of cultural resistance, noting a shift from intense activism to a more fragmented and less visible form, exploring the reasons for this shift, including the perceived need to return to normalcy and the lack of a shared vision on the left.

00:04:52
The Role of Celebrities and Public Figures

The podcast discusses the ongoing relevance of cultural resistance in the face of a Trump administration that actively defies democracy, acknowledging the challenges of defining a unified cultural resistance in the current media landscape and exploring the role of celebrities and public figures in shaping public opinion. It analyzes the Super Bowl as a microcosm of the current cultural moment, highlighting the juxtaposition of Trump's presence at the game with Kendrick Lamar's politically charged halftime performance.

00:25:04
The Democratic Party's Dilemma

The podcast examines the Democratic Party's challenges in the face of Trump's second term, discussing the party's reliance on the "threat to democracy" narrative and the potential pitfalls of this strategy. It also explores the need for Democrats to develop a more concrete and compelling vision for the future. The podcast explores the emergence of new political leaders like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who are utilizing social media platforms to connect with constituents and promote a more progressive vision for America. It discusses the potential for these leaders to resonate with younger voters and challenge the traditional political establishment.

00:37:04
The Democratic Party's Contradictions

The podcast highlights the contradictions within the Democratic Party, particularly regarding its reliance on wealthy donors while advocating for anti-capitalist policies. It explores the challenges of navigating these contradictions and the need for Democrats to address them in a more authentic and consistent manner.

Keywords

Resistance


A collective effort to oppose or challenge a dominant power, ideology, or system. In the context of the podcast, it refers to the opposition to Donald Trump's presidency and his policies.

Cultural Resistance


A form of resistance that manifests through cultural expressions, social movements, and artistic creations. It often involves challenging dominant norms, values, and ideologies through creative and symbolic means.

Hashtag Resistance


A form of cultural resistance that emerged in the digital age, utilizing social media platforms and hashtags to mobilize and amplify messages of dissent. It often involves expressing solidarity and promoting specific causes.

Political Resistance


A form of resistance that involves political action, such as protests, lobbying, and voting. It aims to influence policy decisions and challenge the power structures of government.

Virtue Signaling


The act of publicly expressing opinions or beliefs that are perceived as morally virtuous, often with the intention of gaining social approval or status. It can be seen as a form of performative activism.

Populism


A political ideology that emphasizes the common person and their interests, often in opposition to the perceived elite or establishment. Populist movements often appeal to emotions and grievances, and they can be both left-wing and right-wing.

Anti-Establishment


A sentiment or ideology that opposes the existing power structures and institutions. Anti-establishment movements often challenge traditional authority and advocate for change.

Oligarchy


A form of government in which power is concentrated in the hands of a small, wealthy elite. It is often characterized by corruption, inequality, and a lack of democratic accountability.

Q&A

  • How has the nature of cultural resistance changed since Trump's first term?

    The podcast argues that cultural resistance has become more fragmented and less visible in Trump's second term. This shift is attributed to factors such as the perceived need to return to normalcy, the lack of a shared vision on the left, and the changing media landscape.

  • What is the significance of Joe Rogan's political transformation?

    Rogan's pivot to the far right is seen as indicative of a broader cultural shift, particularly among anti-establishment men who are seeking meaning and value in a system they perceive as broken. His influence on a large audience makes his transformation particularly significant.

  • What are the challenges facing the Democratic Party in the face of Trump's second term?

    The Democratic Party faces challenges in developing a compelling vision for the future, particularly in light of its reliance on wealthy donors while advocating for anti-capitalist policies. The podcast suggests that the party needs to address these contradictions and find a more authentic and consistent approach.

  • How are new political leaders like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez utilizing social media to connect with constituents?

    Ocasio-Cortez is using social media platforms like Instagram to engage in direct dialogue with constituents, providing in-depth explanations of complex issues and promoting actionable items for change. This approach is seen as a potential model for future political leaders.

  • What is the potential for cultural resistance to influence political change?

    The podcast acknowledges the power of cultural resistance in shaping public opinion and challenging dominant narratives. However, it also highlights the challenges of translating cultural resistance into concrete political action, particularly in a polarized and fragmented political landscape.

Show Notes

The essayist and cultural critic Brady Brickner-Wood talks with Tyler Foggatt about the opposition Donald Trump encountered in his first Presidential term, why many liberals are feeling a sense of resignation, and the Democratic Party’s struggle to present a unifying message. Plus, the political commentary embedded in Kendrick Lamar’s Super Bowl halftime show. 


This week’s reading:



To discover more podcasts from The New Yorker, visit newyorker.com/podcasts. To send feedback on this episode, write to themail@newyorker.com.



Learn about your ad choices: dovetail.prx.org/ad-choices
Comments 
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

What Does It Mean to Resist Trump in 2025?

What Does It Mean to Resist Trump in 2025?

The New Yorker